Pueblo Revolt of 1680 Books: The Complete Collecting Guide

On August 10, 1680, coordinated Pueblo warriors struck simultaneously at Spanish missions and settlements across the Rio Grande valley. Within days they had killed more than 400 Spanish colonists and twenty-one of the twenty-three Franciscan friars serving in New Mexico. Governor Antonio de Otermín, wounded twice, led the surviving 2,000 Spanish colonists and allied Native servants on a desperate southward march through the desert to El Paso del Norte. For twelve years the Pueblo people governed their own territory. It was — and remains — the only successful revolt by a Native people against European colonization in North America. No other Indigenous uprising against a European colonial power on this continent achieved territorial expulsion for more than a decade. The 1680 Pueblo Revolt is the central event in New Mexico's pre-territorial history, and the literature documenting it — from foundational seventeenth-century Spanish administrative records through twenty-first-century archaeological analysis — is one of the deepest bodies of regional scholarship in the American West.

The collecting market for Pueblo Revolt literature divides naturally into five strata: the foundational pre-revolt documentary scholarship establishing the conditions (France V. Scholes, 1937-1942); the mid-twentieth-century popular accounts that introduced the revolt to general audiences (Robert Silverberg, 1970); the late-twentieth-century scholarly monographs that applied revisionist social-history methods (Andrew Knaut, 1995); the Pueblo-voice scholarship that re-centers the revolt from within Pueblo oral tradition and community knowledge (Joe Sando, Alfonso Ortiz, the tricentennial commemorations of 1980); and the contemporary archaeological, popular-narrative, and digital-humanities contributions that have substantially expanded the evidentiary base (Matthew Liebmann, David Roberts, the Vargas Project). This guide walks each stratum, identifies the canonical collector targets, and establishes the three-tier market structure that governs pricing at the New Mexico secondary market level.

Last verified May 2026 · Original research by Josh Eldred

The Spanish Colonial Context: What Made the Revolt Possible

Pueblo Revolt of 1680 books are prized collectibles, with early historical accounts and scholarly studies commanding premium prices among Southwest historians. The Pueblo Revolt did not emerge from a single provocation. It was the product of eighty years of compounding Spanish colonial pressures on communities that had been self-governing for centuries before the first Spanish entrada. Understanding the revolt requires understanding the system it destroyed — and the documentary foundation for that system is France V. Scholes's two-volume seventeenth-century New Mexico scholarship.

France Vinton Scholes (1897-1979) was the UNM professor of history who spent his career recovering and analyzing the Spanish administrative, ecclesiastical, and judicial records from the Archivo General de Indias in Seville and the Archivo General de la Nación in Mexico City. His Church and State in New Mexico 1610-1650 (UNM Publications in History, vol. 7, 1937) and Troublous Times in New Mexico 1659-1670 (UNM Publications in History, vol. 11, 1942) are the documentary foundations on which all subsequent revolt scholarship rests. They document not only the Spanish ecclesiastical and civil governance of the Pueblo communities but the deep structural conflict between the Franciscan missionaries and the secular colonial government — a conflict that left the Spanish colonial administration simultaneously coercive toward the Pueblos and internally paralyzed in its response to Pueblo resistance. The friars wanted to suppress Pueblo religious practice entirely; the civil governors wanted Pueblo labor and trade; neither wanted what the other's policies produced. Scholes makes clear that the revolt of 1680 was the culmination of a crisis that had been building for at least half a century. The UNM Publications in History first editions are in genuinely small print runs — institutional copies dominate the surviving population, and private-collection copies in good condition trade at low-three-figure with fine condition crossing higher. These are foundational scholarly documents, not widely circulated trade books.

The encomienda system, through which the Spanish Crown granted New Mexico's encomenderos the right to extract labor and agricultural tribute from Pueblo communities, placed an ongoing tax on Pueblo subsistence production that intersected catastrophically with the prolonged drought and famine conditions of the 1660s and 1670s. The repartimiento system added mandated labor drafts for construction and transport. The Franciscan mission program required Pueblo labor to build the mission churches — the very structures that symbolized the suppression of traditional Pueblo religion. Kiva ceremonies were forbidden. Kachina masks and prayer sticks were confiscated and burned. Traditional Pueblo healers were categorized as sorcerers and subjected to corporal punishment. Governor Juan Francisco de Treviño's 1675 campaign against Pueblo religious practice arrested forty-seven Tewa religious leaders, sentenced them to flogging and slavery, and released them under pressure from Pueblo warriors who marched on Santa Fe demanding their leaders' return. Among those arrested and flogged was a man from Ohkay Owingeh named Po'pay.

The organizational achievement of the 1680 revolt lay in coordinating communities that spoke at least six distinct, mutually unintelligible languages (Tewa, Tiwa, Towa, Keresan, Zuni, and Hopi) across a geographic range of more than 400 miles from Taos in the north to the Hopi mesas in the west — communities that had often been rivals and that shared no historical tradition of unified political action. Po'pay organized from Taos Pueblo, communicating the planned revolt date to participating Pueblos through runners carrying knotted cords, each knot representing one day remaining until the uprising. When two runners were captured on August 9 and disclosed the plan, Po'pay moved the date up by one day. The revolt launched on August 10, 1680.

August 10, 1680: The Revolt and Governor Otermín's Retreat

Antonio de Otermín, the Spanish Governor of New Mexico in August 1680, was in Santa Fe when the revolt broke out. He survived two arrow wounds and managed to gather several hundred survivors in the Governor's Palace on the Santa Fe Plaza before being forced to abandon the city and begin the retreat south. The retreating Spanish column passed through Isleta Pueblo and made its way to El Paso del Norte — the present-day El Paso/Ciudad Juárez area — arriving in late September 1680 with roughly 2,000 survivors out of a population of approximately 2,800 Spanish colonists and allied Native workers. Otermín's own account, the Carta sobre la rebelión de los indios in 1680, is a primary Spanish document available in English translation in Charles Wilson Hackett's two-volume Revolt of the Pueblo Indians of New Mexico and Otermín's Attempted Reconquest, 1680-1682 (UNM Press, 1942) — an essential primary-source compilation that any serious collection of revolt literature should include.

Hackett's 1942 two-volume primary-source compilation sits adjacent to the Scholes monographs in the foundational pre-modern collector tier. Hackett (1888-1951) was the University of Texas professor who translated and edited the principal Spanish documentary record of the revolt and the failed 1681-1682 Otermín reconquest attempt. The two-volume set in fine condition with matched original dust jackets is a Tier 2 collector target; fine matched sets are more accessible than the small-print-run Scholes UNM Publications in History volumes but substantially less common than the post-1970 trade histories. Any annotated or association copy (ex-library copies of major NM historians' own working copies) would move toward Tier 1.

The revolt itself killed 401 Spanish colonists and twenty-one Franciscan friars — nearly every friar serving in New Mexico. Pueblo warriors expelled the Spanish from all of their settlements in the province. The mission churches were burned, the baptismal records were destroyed (Po'pay reportedly ordered Pueblo people to wash off their baptisms in the Rio Grande), and the kivas and kachina ceremonial systems were publicly restored. Pueblo leaders reclaimed the lands the Spanish had occupied around the major Rio Grande Pueblos. The Spanish colonial capital of Santa Fe, built on Tewa Pueblo land seized by Pedro de Peralta in 1610, reverted to Pueblo occupation. The Palace of the Governors on the Santa Fe Plaza — the oldest continuously occupied public building in the United States, built 1610 — was converted for Pueblo habitation, its rooms partitioned and its main entrance blocked.

Robert Silverberg and the Early Popular Literature, 1970

Robert Silverberg's The Pueblo Revolt (Weybright and Talley, New York, 1970) was the first popular-trade-market book to bring the story of the 1680 revolt to a general American audience. Silverberg (b. 1935) was — and remains — primarily known as a prolific science fiction writer, but his nonfiction career in the 1950s through early 1970s produced a substantial series of popular American history narratives, and The Pueblo Revolt is among the best of them. The book is briskly written, narrative-forward, and draws on the Hackett translations and on the then-available secondary scholarship with reasonable fidelity. It is not a work of original archival scholarship and its interpretive framework has been substantially revised by subsequent work — particularly the Pueblo-voice scholarship of Sando and Ortiz and the social-history revisionism of Andrew Knaut — but it established the revolt as a subject with popular-market commercial viability and introduced the narrative to hundreds of thousands of readers who might otherwise never have encountered it.

The Weybright and Talley 1970 first edition in fine condition with original dust jacket is the collector target. The book was subsequently reissued in multiple paperback formats and remains accessible in mass-market paperback in the secondary market; the 1970 first in jacket is the Tier 2 trophy for an early popular accounts section of a revolt collection. Silverberg signed extensively throughout his long career at science fiction conventions and book events; signed copies of The Pueblo Revolt are present in the secondary market but less common than signed science fiction Silverberg. The book's role in the historiography is as the bridge between the pre-1970 archival scholarship (Scholes, Hackett) and the post-1980 revisionist wave — it is the text that made the 1680 revolt a story general American readers knew.

The Tricentennial and the Pueblo Voice: 1980 Commemorations

The tricentennial of the 1680 revolt in 1980 was a major moment in the historiography. A series of conferences, commemorative publications, and political assertions by Pueblo communities collectively reframed the revolt from a regional historical curiosity into a live political and cultural question. The 1980 tricentennial commemorations produced a corpus of pamphlets, conference proceedings, newspaper features, and short monographs that represent a distinct collecting category: ephemeral tricentennial material. Museum of New Mexico publications, School of American Research press papers, and New Mexico Historical Review special issues from the 1980 tricentennial year are the key ephemeral targets — most survive only in institutional library holdings, and individual copies in good condition trade upper-two-figure when they appear in specialist New Mexico dealers' catalogs.

The tricentennial also accelerated the Pueblo-voice scholarly program. Joe S. Sando (1923-2011, Jemez Pueblo) was the most prominent Pueblo historian of the modern period, and his treatment of the revolt in Pueblo Nations: Eight Centuries of Pueblo Indian History (Clear Light Publishers, Santa Fe, 1992; revised 1998) represents the definitive Pueblo-internal historical perspective on 1680. Sando's methodology drew on Pueblo oral tradition, tribal-internal genealogical knowledge, and Pueblo language sources that the secular documentary historians had not incorporated. His account of Po'pay — not the tyrant of Spanish post-revolt testimony, but the liberator who freed his people from a colonial system of coerced labor and religious suppression — represents a fundamentally different reading from the one available in Spanish administrative records alone. The Clear Light Publishers 1992 first edition of Pueblo Nations in fine condition with original dust jacket is the Tier 2 collector target; signed Sando copies are present in the market from his years of signing at Santa Fe and Albuquerque events but are not abundant. Sando's pool closed in 2011.

Alfonso Ortiz (1939-1997, San Juan Pueblo / Ohkay Owingeh) was a UNM Department of Anthropology professor who edited Volumes 9 and 10 of the Smithsonian Handbook of North American Indians — the two Southwest volumes (1979 and 1983) that remain the standard reference for Pueblo and Pueblo-adjacent communities. Ortiz's own scholarly work on Tewa cosmology and social organization, The Tewa World: Space, Time, Being, and Becoming in a Pueblo Society (University of Chicago Press, 1969), is essential background reading for understanding what the Franciscan suppression of Pueblo religion was destroying. The Smithsonian Handbook Southwest volumes are large, expensive, heavy, and now uncommon in matched fine condition; collectors target the original Smithsonian Institution Press printings. Ortiz's pool closed in 1997. Signed Ortiz copies from The Tewa World trade upper-three-figure when they appear.

The context of Ohkay Owingeh — Ortiz's and Po'pay's home pueblo, historically known by the Spanish name San Juan Pueblo — gives the Ortiz scholarly contribution a particular weight in the 1680 collecting library. The community that produced both the leading Pueblo-voice anthropologist of the twentieth century and the architect of the revolt itself is the geographic and cultural center of the revolt historiography. Ohkay Owingeh's formal reclamation of its Tewa name in 2005 — the same year Po'pay's statue was placed in the U.S. Capitol — was itself a historiographical event, completing a re-centering of Pueblo identity that the 1980 tricentennial had begun.

John Kessell: Kiva, Cross, and Crown and the Vargas Project

John L. Kessell's Kiva, Cross, and Crown: The Pecos Indians and New Mexico 1540-1840 (National Park Service, 1979; UNM Press reissue 1987; revised UNM Press 2008) traces the full history of Pecos Pueblo from first Spanish contact through its abandonment in 1838. The revolt chapters are among the most richly documented accounts of how a specific major Pueblo community experienced the 1680 uprising, the twelve-year independence period, and the Spanish reconquista. Pecos's strategic position — at the gateway between the Rio Grande Pueblos and the Great Plains, the principal trade junction between Pueblo farmers and plains bison hunters — made its alliances and decisions pivotal to both the revolt's initial success and Vargas's subsequent reconquest. Kessell's mastery of the Spanish archival record for Pecos and its surrounding district makes the revolt chapters essential reading alongside the dedicated revolt monographs. The National Park Service 1979 first edition softcover is the collector target from the original publication context; the 1987 UNM Press reissue hardcover is more common and is the standard working reference for most researchers. Signed Kessell copies trade Tier 2 when they appear.

Kessell's larger contribution to the post-revolt literature is the Vargas Project — the six-volume scholarly edition of the Journals of don Diego de Vargas (UNM Press, 1989-2002), the primary-source record for the Spanish reconquest of 1692-1704. The six volumes are: Remote Beyond Compare: Letters of don Diego de Vargas to His Family from New Spain and New Mexico, 1675-1706 (1989); By Force of Arms: The Journals of don Diego de Vargas, 1691-1693 (1992); To the Royal Crown Restored: The Journals of don Diego de Vargas, 1692-1694 (1995); Blood on the Boulders: The Journals of don Diego de Vargas, 1694-1697 (1998); That Disturbances Cease: The Journals of don Diego de Vargas, 1697-1700 (2000); A Settling of Accounts: The Journals of don Diego de Vargas, 1700-1704 (2002). Co-editors across the series include Rick Hendricks (later New Mexico State Historian 2011-2020), Meredith D. Dodge, and Larry D. Miller. A complete six-volume set in fine condition with original dust jackets is a Tier 1 collector object trading mid-three-to-low-four-figure at specialist Western Americana dealers; signed sets command upper four figures at Heritage or Swann specialist auction.

Diego de Vargas and the Reconquista, 1692-1696

Diego de Vargas Zapata Luján Ponce de León y Contreras (1643-1704) was the Spanish Governor appointed to reconquer New Mexico in 1691. He led an advance party into New Mexico in September 1692, entering Santa Fe and symbolically accepting the submission of Pueblo communities in what has been termed a "bloodless reconquest" — though the qualifier is substantially qualified by the events of the following four years. The initial 1692 entrada was indeed largely without armed conflict; most Pueblo communities symbolically submitted to Vargas and received formal pardon from the Spanish Crown. The military reconquest of 1693-1696 was a different matter. A renewed Pueblo uprising in 1693-1694, centered at Santa Fe itself where Pueblo occupants of the Palace of the Governors refused to yield the building, was suppressed by force. A further coordinated Pueblo uprising in 1696, involving five or six Pueblos in the central Rio Grande valley, was also suppressed militarily. By 1696 Spanish colonial authority was re-established, though the Pueblo communities had extracted significant concessions — the encomienda system was substantially weakened, the most coercive Franciscan suppression of Pueblo ceremonial practice was moderated, and the legal fiction of Pueblo land-grant rights was more consistently observed. The post-reconquista colonial arrangement was different enough from the pre-revolt arrangement that historians generally treat 1692 as a watershed, not merely a restoration.

The historiographical tension in the Reconquista literature is between the Spanish hagiographic tradition (Vargas as heroic reconqueror, celebrated annually in Santa Fe's Fiesta de Santa Fe since 1712 as "La Entrada") and the Pueblo critical tradition (the reconquest as a second conquest, with Vargas's clemency as a political performance masking continued coercion). This tension is documented across the Vargas Journals volumes, where Vargas's own correspondence reveals both his strategic calculation in presenting clemency as the dominant narrative and the violence underlying the 1693-1696 military campaign. The Fiesta de Santa Fe's "La Entrada" reenactment has been a site of ongoing Pueblo protest since at least the 1990s and was cancelled or modified in 2020-2021 following the removal of the Oñate statue in Alcalde. Collectors of the Reconquista literature should be aware that the political context of this scholarship has been active and contested within living memory, not a settled historical question.

Have books you're ready to part with? I offer free pickup across Albuquerque — call 702-496-4214.

Andrew Knaut: The Scholarly Monograph Standard, 1995

Andrew Knaut's The Pueblo Revolt of 1680: Conquest and Resistance in Seventeenth-Century New Mexico (University of Oklahoma Press, 1995) is the principal modern scholarly monograph on the revolt. Knaut (then at the University of Minnesota) drew on both Spanish archival sources and the growing revisionist literature of the 1980s and early 1990s — incorporating the social-history methods pioneered by Ramón Gutiérrez's When Jesus Came, the Corn Mothers Went Away (Stanford, 1991) alongside the Pueblo-voice corrections offered by Sando, Ortiz, and the tricentennial scholarship — to produce the most comprehensive single-volume scholarly treatment of the revolt's conditions, causes, and course. The book is particularly strong on the structural analysis of the encomienda-repartimiento-mission system and on the specific sequence of events in the 1675-1680 buildup period. Its treatment of Po'pay is more balanced than Silverberg's 1970 popular account — acknowledging both the Spanish post-revolt characterizations (which were hostile) and the Pueblo-voice counter-narrative — while remaining grounded in the available documentary evidence rather than privileging either source tradition.

The University of Oklahoma Press 1995 first hardcover in fine condition with original dust jacket is the Tier 2 collector target — a canonical scholarly monograph with a modest print run that has not been reissued in a substantially expanded revised edition. Signed Knaut copies are uncommon. The book remains in print in the Oklahoma Press paperback and continues to be the standard scholarly monograph assignment in UNM, NMSU, and other southwestern university courses on New Mexico history and Pueblo history.

France Scholes's Foundation: Church and State in New Mexico

A full account of the 1680 Pueblo Revolt collecting library requires returning to the foundational documentary scholarship and treating it with the same depth given to the post-1970 monographs. France Scholes's Church and State in New Mexico 1610-1650 (UNM Publications in History, vol. 7, 1937) is the essential documentary foundation — the closest thing the historiography has to a comprehensive archive of the conditions that made the revolt possible. Scholes's second volume, Troublous Times in New Mexico 1659-1670 (UNM Publications in History, vol. 11, 1942), covers the decade immediately preceding the most coercive phase of Spanish religious suppression. Together they document the century-long buildup of the grievances that Po'pay and the Pueblo leaders of 1680 organized around.

The articles that preceded and expanded these volumes are also collecting targets: Scholes published extensively in the New Mexico Historical Review from the late 1920s through the early 1940s, and the NMHR issues containing his foundational articles — particularly the 1935-1942 run in which the Church and State arguments were developed in article form before consolidation in the monographs — are part of the institutional documentary record. NMHR back issues from this period in good condition trade upper-two-figure to low-three-figure; a run of the relevant issues is a genuine research tool. Scholes's work was continued by Jack Forbes, Carroll Riley, and eventually Knaut; the chain of citation from Scholes forward is unbroken through the entire modern revolt literature.

David Roberts and the Popular Narrative Revival, 2004

David Roberts's The Pueblo Revolt: The Secret Rebellion That Drove the Spaniards Out of the Southwest (Simon and Schuster, 2004) is the most polished and commercially successful popular-narrative treatment of the revolt since Silverberg's 1970 book. Roberts is a veteran narrative-nonfiction writer with a substantial backlist of Southwest exploration and archaeology books (In Search of the Old Ones, 1996; The Pueblo Revolt, 2004; The Lost World of the Old Ones, 2015), and he brings professional craft and accessible narrative technique to the revolt story without sacrificing historical accuracy. The book draws on the major post-1970 scholarly literature — Knaut, Sando, Ortiz, Kessell — and incorporates Roberts's own on-the-ground travel through revolt-era sites. It is the book most general readers encounter first when they encounter the revolt at all outside academic contexts, and it has driven significant interest in the deeper scholarly literature.

The Simon and Schuster 2004 first hardcover in fine condition with original dust jacket is the Tier 2 collector target. Roberts signed at multiple Southwest bookstore events through the 2000s; signed first copies trade Tier 2 at specialist dealers. The book remains in print in Simon and Schuster trade paperback. Roberts's popular treatment of the revolt and Silverberg's 1970 popular account together constitute the popular narrative pillar of the revolt collecting library — the books that brought the story to general readers in each generation.

Matthew Liebmann and the Archaeological Turn, 2012

Matthew Liebmann's Revolt: An Archaeological History of Pueblo Resistance and Revitalization in the Seventeenth Century (University of Arizona Press, 2012) is the methodological breakthrough of the contemporary revolt literature. Liebmann, a Harvard anthropologist, conducted multi-season archaeological fieldwork on the mesa-top refuge pueblos of the Jemez Plateau — the fortified communities established or significantly enlarged during the revolt and independence period by Pueblo communities seeking defensible positions from which to resist Spanish reconquest. The Jemez Mountains sites include Patokwa, Boletsakwa, and Astialakwa — Towa-speaking Jemez Pueblo communities that relocated to mesa-top fortified positions in 1680 and remained there through portions of the independence period before moving again during the Vargas reconquest. The archaeological record of these sites provides direct material evidence of how Pueblo communities organized themselves during the twelve years of independence — evidence that no surviving Spanish administrative document can supply, because no Spanish officials were present in New Mexico to observe and record what the Pueblos were doing from 1680 to 1692.

Liebmann's theoretical contribution is a developed account of revitalization movements — drawing on Anthony Wallace's 1956 anthropological model of cultural revitalization in post-contact Indigenous communities — applied specifically to the archaeological evidence from the Jemez sites. The material culture of the refuge pueblos shows deliberate revival of pre-contact architectural styles, abandonment of Spanish-introduced material culture, and reassertion of traditional ceremonial spatial organization in community layouts. The archaeology demonstrates that the twelve-year independence period was not merely a political interregnum but a sustained cultural revitalization program, a conscious effort to reconstitute pre-contact Pueblo lifeways that the Spanish colonial period had suppressed. This archaeological evidence is not available from any documentary source and is the principal scholarly contribution of the book to the revolt literature. The University of Arizona Press 2012 first edition in fine condition with original dust jacket is the Tier 1 collector target among contemporary scholarly revolt titles. The book remains in print and is regularly assigned in graduate-level Southwestern archaeology and Southwest history seminars.

Alfonso Ortiz's Smithsonian Handbook and the Pueblo Cultural Reference

The Smithsonian Institution's Handbook of North American Indians series — twenty large volumes covering the full range of North American Indigenous cultures, published from the mid-1970s through the 1990s — includes two Southwest volumes that are essential to any serious Pueblo Revolt collecting library: Volume 9: Southwest (Smithsonian Institution Press, 1979) and Volume 10: Southwest (Smithsonian Institution Press, 1983), both edited by Alfonso Ortiz. Volume 9 covers the Pueblo peoples; Volume 10 covers the non-Pueblo Southwest. Volume 9 in particular is the standard reference for Pueblo community histories, social organization, ceremonial systems, and material culture — the reference that any serious reader of the revolt literature needs alongside the historical monographs, because the revolt can only be fully understood in the context of the specific social and ceremonial structures it was defending. The Smithsonian Handbook volumes were expensive when new (the common reading copy to mid-range zone each in 1979-1983 dollars), are large-format, and now survive in institutional libraries and a relatively small number of serious private collections in matched fine condition. Individual volumes in good condition trade low-three-figure; matched sets in fine condition command mid-to-upper three figures. Original Smithsonian Institution Press printings are the collector target rather than later reprints.

The Tewa World: Space, Time, Being, and Becoming in a Pueblo Society (University of Chicago Press, 1969), Ortiz's single-author monograph on Tewa cosmology and social structure, is the essential companion volume to both the Handbook and the revolt literature. Understanding what the Franciscan suppression of Pueblo religion was destroying — the specific ceremonial calendar, the moiety social structure, the kachina responsibility system, the kiva organization, the agricultural ritual complex — requires the kind of deep ethnographic analysis that The Tewa World provides. The University of Chicago Press 1969 first hardcover in fine condition with original dust jacket is the Tier 2 collector target. Signed Ortiz copies are scarce and trade upper-three-figure when authenticated — Ortiz's pool closed in 1997.

Po'pay in the United States Capitol: The 2005 Statuary Hall Placement

In 2005, the State of New Mexico replaced one of its two contributions to the National Statuary Hall in the United States Capitol. New Mexico's two statues in the collection are Dennis Chávez — the longtime U.S. Senator and champion of civil rights — and Po'pay. The Po'pay statue, sculpted by Cliff Fragua (Jemez Pueblo), depicts the revolt leader with a knotted cord in one hand, a gesture referencing the cord system through which Po'pay communicated the revolt date to participating Pueblos. The placement was the result of a years-long campaign by Pueblo communities, particularly through the All Indian Pueblo Council and the Pueblo de Ohkay Owingeh (which formally reclaimed the name Ohkay Owingeh from San Juan Pueblo in the same year). The 2005 Capitol placement generated a substantial ephemeral literature: Congressional testimony, Indian Pueblo Cultural Center programs, commemorative pamphlets, New Mexico Historical Review features, and the Joe Sando / Herman Agoyo edited collection.

Po'pay: Leader of the First American Revolution, edited by Joe S. Sando and Herman Agoyo (Clear Light Publishers, Santa Fe, 2005), was published in conjunction with the Capitol placement. The book gathers Pueblo scholars, historians, and cultural leaders offering assessments of Po'pay's historical significance and contemporary meaning for Pueblo communities. It is simultaneously a scholarly collection and a political-cultural document — the Pueblo communities' formal scholarly statement on the meaning of the revolt and its architect, published at the moment of his national commemoration. The Clear Light 2005 first edition in fine condition with original dust jacket is the Tier 1 Pueblo-voice collector target from the revolt literature. Sando signed at the Capitol placement ceremony and at subsequent Santa Fe and Albuquerque events; signed copies are in the secondary market. Herman Agoyo signed less frequently; signed co-editor copies are scarcer. Sando's pool closed in 2011. The book is the contemporary Pueblo-voice standard and is essential to any revolt collecting library that includes the broader Pueblo scholarly tradition.

I pick up books for free anywhere in the metro area. Call 702-496-4214 to schedule.

The Broader Context: Kessell's Vargas Project as Reconquista Primary Source

The Vargas Project multi-volume journals are the primary-source foundation for the reconquista era, and any collector approaching the revolt literature from a comprehensive perspective will need at minimum the first three volumes (1989, 1992, 1995) covering the 1691-1695 period of the initial reconquest. The full six-volume set is the canonical collector object; partial sets are common in the secondary market because the volumes were published across thirteen years and estate donations frequently yield only the first two or three that a household acquired before losing interest or moving. Identifying completeness requires checking all six full title pages (not just spines), verifying matched dust-jacket condition, and cross-referencing the co-editor progression (Kessell solo in vol. 1; Kessell and Hendricks in vols. 2-3; Kessell, Hendricks, and Dodge in vols. 4-6). A complete matched-jacket fine set is the standard Tier 1 trophy from the entire Kessell corpus; individual volumes in good condition are accessible at lower-three-figure and assembling a complete set across patient multi-year acquisition is realistic for a budget-disciplined collector.

Kessell's Spain in the Southwest: A Narrative History of Colonial New Mexico, Arizona, Texas, and California (University of Oklahoma Press, 2002) provides the synthetic regional context that places the revolt and reconquista within the broader Spanish colonial Southwest. The University of Oklahoma Press 2002 first hardcover in fine condition is a Tier 2 collector target. Kessell's Pueblos, Spaniards, and the Kingdom of New Mexico (University of Oklahoma Press, 2008) is the most recent of his synthetic treatments and represents a mature synthesis of the Vargas Project scholarship with the broader colonial literature. Together the three Kessell monographs — Kiva Cross and Crown, Spain in the Southwest, and Pueblos Spaniards and the Kingdom — constitute a comprehensive three-volume synthetic treatment of the colonial period surrounding the revolt.

The Gutiérrez Question: Social History and Its Pueblo Critique

No survey of the 1680 revolt literature is complete without addressing Ramón A. Gutiérrez's When Jesus Came, the Corn Mothers Went Away: Marriage, Sexuality, and Power in New Mexico, 1500-1846 (Stanford University Press, 1991). Gutiérrez's book is not specifically about the 1680 revolt, but its argument — that the Franciscan mission system's reorganization of Pueblo marriage, sexuality, gender, and household authority was a central driver of the tensions leading to the revolt — made it essential reading in the revolt literature and generated the most important scholarly controversy in twentieth-century New Mexico colonial historiography. The Stanford 1991 first edition with original dust jacket is a Tier 1 collector target for the broader colonial literature and a Tier 2 target for revolt-specific collecting. The controversy itself — including the 1993 American Indian Culture and Research Journal special issue with responses from Sando, Ortiz, and other Pueblo and Native scholars — is part of the historiographical record of the revolt literature and belongs in any serious collection approaching the scholarship historically rather than just topically.

Five Identification Problems for Revolt Collectors

Problem one: Kessell Kiva, Cross, and Crown — NPS first vs UNM Press reissue vs revised edition. The National Park Service 1979 first edition softcover is the foundational first publication and is the collector target for completeness. The 1987 UNM Press reissue (hardcover and softcover) is more common and is the standard working reference in most libraries. The revised 2008 UNM Press edition incorporates updated scholarship. All three have collector merit; the NPS 1979 is the Tier 1 object, the 1987 UNM Press first hardcover is Tier 2, and the 2008 revised is the working reference. Spine identification: NPS editions carry "National Park Service" on spine; UNM editions carry UNM Press imprint. Confusing the two is the most common Kessell identification error in general-market estate sales.

Problem two: Hackett Revolt of the Pueblo Indians two-volume set — matching volumes. Charles Wilson Hackett's Revolt of the Pueblo Indians of New Mexico and Otermín's Attempted Reconquest, 1680-1682 (UNM Press, 1942, two volumes) is the principal primary-source document collection for the revolt itself and the failed 1681-1682 reconquest attempt. The two volumes were sold together but are frequently separated in estate donations; single-volume offerings should be priced at significant discount relative to fine matched sets. The Hackett volumes are among the genuinely scarce Tier 2 items in the revolt collecting market — small print run, 1942 wartime paper quality, eighty-plus years of attrition. Library copies with institutional bindings are common; original-binding copies in good or better condition are substantially less so.

Problem three: Sando Pueblo Nations 1992 Clear Light first vs 1998 revised. The 1992 Clear Light first edition and the 1998 revised edition are both in trade-paperback format and look nearly identical at quick examination. The 1992 first is the collector target; verify via copyright page date. The 1998 revised incorporates updated material and is slightly more common in the secondary market. Both carry signed-copy premium when authenticated — Sando signed at Santa Fe and Albuquerque events regularly through his later years.

Problem four: Tricentennial ephemeral material — identification and provenance. The 1980 tricentennial generated a substantial corpus of short-run publications, conference programs, and museum pamphlets that are genuinely difficult to catalog without access to specialist New Mexico rare-book dealer databases or the UNM Center for Southwest Research finding aids. The safest approach is to date-verify all undated or ambiguously dated pamphlet-format material before pricing. Tricentennial material in collectible condition carries meaningful premium at Old Santa Fe Trail Books and similar specialist dealers; standard general-market pricing often undervalues it.

Problem five: Vargas Journals six-volume completeness — co-editor variations as confirmation. The six volumes of the Kessell Vargas Journals were published by different editorial teams across thirteen years. Vol. 1 (1989): Kessell sole editor. Vols. 2-3 (1992, 1995): Kessell and Hendricks co-editors. Vols. 4-6 (1998, 2000, 2002): Kessell, Hendricks, and Dodge co-editors. A "complete set" that shows the wrong co-editor pattern on any spine (or that shows Dodge credited on an early volume) is either mislabeled or not original. The co-editor progression is also useful for quick publication-order confirmation without title-page lookup.

Three-Tier Collector Market

Tier 1 trophy (mid-three-figure to low-four-figure): Complete Kessell Vargas Journals six-volume matched-jacket fine set (Tier 1 at mid-three-figure; signed Kessell or Hendricks crosses four-figure at specialist auction); Matthew Liebmann Revolt 2012 University of Arizona Press first signed by author in fine condition; signed Alfonso Ortiz The Tewa World 1969 University of Chicago Press first hardcover authenticated (Ortiz pool closed 1997); Hackett Revolt of the Pueblo Indians 1942 UNM Press two-volume matched-binding fine condition; signed Joe Sando Pueblo Nations 1992 Clear Light first in fine condition (pool closed 2011); signed Joe Sando / Herman Agoyo Po'pay 2005 Clear Light first in fine condition; France Scholes Church and State in New Mexico 1937 UNM Publications in History vol. 7 first fine condition; France Scholes Troublous Times 1942 UNM Publications in History vol. 11 first fine condition; NPS 1979 Kessell Kiva, Cross, and Crown first softcover in fine condition (particularly association copies with marginalia or signatures from major revolt scholars); Robert Silverberg The Pueblo Revolt 1970 Weybright and Talley first hardcover in fine dust jacket signed by author.

Tier 2 collector targets (low-to-mid three-figure): Andrew Knaut The Pueblo Revolt of 1680 1995 University of Oklahoma Press first hardcover with dust jacket; David Roberts The Pueblo Revolt 2004 Simon and Schuster first hardcover with dust jacket signed by author; 1987 UNM Press Kessell Kiva, Cross, and Crown first hardcover reissue in fine condition; signed Kessell monographs (Spain in the Southwest 2002 Oklahoma first, Pueblos Spaniards 2008 Oklahoma first); Ramón Gutiérrez When Jesus Came 1991 Stanford first hardcover with dust jacket; Alfonso Ortiz The Tewa World 1969 Chicago first hardcover without signed copy (unsigned); Smithsonian Handbook of North American Indians volumes 9 and 10 (Southwest) in matched fine condition original Smithsonian press printings; Joe Sando Nee Hemish 1982 UNM Press first in fine condition; Robert Silverberg The Pueblo Revolt 1970 Weybright and Talley first unsigned in good or better condition with dust jacket; Hackett Revolt of the Pueblo Indians 1942 two volumes in good condition (less-than-fine condition).

Tier 3 working library (upper-two-figure to low-three-figure): Subsequent printings and paperback reissues of all of the above; UNM Press paperback editions of canonical revolt hardcovers; Clear Light Publishers softcover Sando titles (Pueblo Indians 1976, Pueblo Nations 1998 revised paperback); David Roberts The Pueblo Revolt trade paperback; Andrew Knaut Oklahoma Press trade paperback; New Mexico Historical Review back issues containing foundational revolt articles (particularly the 1980 tricentennial issue and surrounding years); tricentennial pamphlets and museum publications in good condition; School of American Research Press Pueblo papers; Popular Science series Southwest archaeology titles with significant revolt content; individual Vargas Journals volumes in good condition (building toward a complete set); Kessell Spain in the Southwest 2002 Oklahoma paperback; introductory-level New Mexico history textbooks with significant revolt chapters; general Southwest popular-history trade paperbacks (Silverberg reissues, Roberts paperback).

Institutional Holdings and Research Collections

The principal institutional repositories for revolt-related documentation and scholarship are clustered in Santa Fe and Albuquerque, with significant holdings in the Pueblos themselves. The Fray Angélico Chávez History Library in the Palace of the Governors complex on the Santa Fe Plaza holds the Spanish Archives of New Mexico (SANM I and SANM II) — the two principal colonial-period administrative document collections containing the pre-revolt governors' correspondence, the encomienda records, and the ecclesiastical documentation of the 1675 religious-leader arrests. The UNM Center for Southwest Research in Albuquerque's Zimmerman Library holds the papers of major twentieth-century revolt scholars, including working files and correspondence that illuminate the scholarly debates. The Archives of the Archdiocese of Santa Fe (Catholic Center, 4000 St. Joseph Place NW Albuquerque) holds the ecclesiastical documentation of the Franciscan mission program, the sacramental records that documented Pueblo communities under the missions, and the records of the post-revolt reconstitution of the missions after 1692.

The Indian Pueblo Cultural Center in Albuquerque maintains a library and archive of Pueblo-authored and Pueblo-focused scholarship with significant revolt holdings, including the tricentennial publications and the Sando / Agoyo 2005 Po'pay collection. The Poeh Cultural Center at Pojoaque Pueblo north of Santa Fe maintains holdings relevant to the northern Rio Grande Pueblo communities most directly involved in the revolt. The Palace of the Governors Photo Archives holds photographic documentation of revolt-related sites and commemorative events including the tricentennial. The New Mexico State Records Center and Archives in Santa Fe holds the post-reconquest New Mexico Territorial Records, the period beginning with Vargas in 1693.

The New Mexico Historical Review, published continuously since 1926 by the Historical Society of New Mexico, is the principal peer-reviewed journal for revolt scholarship. The NMHR back-issue run from 1926 through the present is a collecting target in its own right — individual NMHR issues containing major revolt articles (the Scholes articles of the 1930s-1940s, the tricentennial-year 1980 special features, the Knaut and Liebmann-era survey articles) trade upper-two-figure to low-three-figure at specialist dealers. A complete NMHR run from 1926 forward is held only at major research libraries.

Building the Collection: A Sequenced Acquisition Approach

A serious Pueblo Revolt collecting library is not assembled in a single acquisition — it is built over time across specialist dealers, estate sales, regional auction, and institutional sources. The sequenced approach that produces the best balance of depth and investment is as follows.

Foundation phase: Acquire the standard working references first — the Knaut Oklahoma Press 1995 paperback or first hardcover, the Roberts Simon and Schuster 2004 trade paperback or first hardcover, the Sando Clear Light Pueblo Nations 1992 or 1998 revised paperback, the Liebmann Arizona Press 2012 paperback, and the Kessell UNM Press Kiva, Cross, and Crown 1987 reissue paperback or hardcover. This five-book foundation is acquirable for under respectable collector value total in good secondary-market condition and provides the full scholarly and popular-narrative range. Add the Hackett Revolt of the Pueblo Indians 1942 two-volume set when it appears at a specialist dealer — this is the primary-source base that the entire modern literature rests on.

Depth phase: Add the Scholes Church and State 1937 and Troublous Times 1942 UNM Publications in History first editions (the conditions-and-context foundation), the Sando / Agoyo Po'pay 2005 Clear Light first (the Pueblo-voice treatment), and the Smithsonian Handbook Southwest volumes 9 and 10 (the cultural reference). Begin assembling Vargas Journals volumes — start with volumes 2 and 3 (By Force of Arms 1992 and To the Royal Crown Restored 1995, the core reconquista journals) and add others as fine-condition copies appear.

Trophy phase: Target complete Vargas Journals six-volume matched-jacket fine sets when they appear intact (rare in single-donation context); signed Sando Pueblo Nations 1992 Clear Light first authenticated; signed Kessell Kiva Cross and Crown or Vargas Journals; Gutiérrez Stanford 1991 first hardcover with dust jacket; Silverberg Weybright and Talley 1970 first hardcover signed. At this phase you are building the collection's trophy tier from a foundation that already provides comprehensive coverage of the revolt literature.

Not sure what you have? Text me a photo at 702-496-4214 and I'll tell you what I see.

NMLP Intake Position

Pueblo Revolt books arrive at NMLP through three principal demographic streams: UNM faculty and graduate-student estate donations (heavy scholarly holdings including the academic press monographs, journal runs, and institutional publications); Santa Fe and northern New Mexico Pueblo-community and Hispano-heritage households (Pueblo-voice scholarship, Clear Light Publishers titles, Indian Pueblo Cultural Center and Poeh Cultural Center publications, tricentennial ephemera); and general Albuquerque regional-history households (popular narrative trade books, Silverberg reissues, Roberts paperbacks, Smithsonian-adjacent popular histories).

Tier 1 trophy items route to specialist New Mexico history dealers (SellBooksABQ, Old Santa Fe Trail Books, Collected Works Santa Fe, Books On The Bosque) or specialist auction (Heritage Western Americana, Swann Galleries Books and Manuscripts, Bonhams). Tier 2 trade firsts route through SellBooksABQ standard hand-sort. Tier 3 subsequent printings, paperback reissues, and popular New Mexico history titles route to APS Title I schools — particularly relevant given the New Mexico History and Social Studies curriculum's significant requirements around Pueblo history and the 1680 revolt — the UNM Children's Hospital reading program, regional library partnership network, and Little Free Library stocking. New Mexico Native American cultural material with institutional research value routes to the Indian Pueblo Cultural Center, Poeh Cultural Center, UNM Center for Southwest Research, or the Fray Angélico Chávez History Library when the material has institutional research value beyond standard secondary market resale.

Free statewide pickup anywhere in New Mexico with no condition limit and no minimum quantity. Call or text 702-496-4214 to schedule. Books on the Pueblo Revolt, New Mexico colonial history, Pueblo culture, and the broader Southwest history canon are among the materials I most actively work to place with researchers, students, and community libraries across the state.

External References

• University of Oklahoma Press — publisher of Knaut's The Pueblo Revolt of 1680 (1995)
• University of New Mexico Press — Vargas Project, Kessell, Scholes; principal academic NM publisher
• University of Arizona Press — publisher of Liebmann's Revolt (2012)
• Clear Light Publishers, Santa Fe — Sando's Pueblo Nations (1992) and Po'pay: Leader of the First American Revolution (2005)
• Fray Angélico Chávez History Library — Spanish Archives of New Mexico, principal colonial document repository
• UNM Center for Southwest Research — twentieth-century revolt scholars' papers
• Indian Pueblo Cultural Center, Albuquerque — Pueblo-voice library and archive, revolt-related holdings
• New Mexico State Records Center and Archives — post-reconquista New Mexico records from 1693 forward
• Wikipedia: Po'pay
• Wikipedia: Pueblo Revolt
• Wikipedia: Diego de Vargas
• Wikipedia: Antonio de Otermín
• Wikipedia: Alfonso Ortiz
• Wikipedia: Joe S. Sando

Related on This Site

• New Mexico Spanish Colonial Historians — Simmons, Kessell, Chávez, Scholes, Hammond & Rey — the broader colonial canon surrounding the revolt
• Pueblo Pottery Books — Pueblo-voice material culture scholarship overlapping the Sando and Ortiz traditions
• New Mexico Native American Literature — Simon Ortiz, Leslie Marmon Silko, and the literary tradition emerging from Pueblo communities
• Pueblo Revival Architecture Books — the twentieth-century appropriation and reinvention of Pueblo aesthetic traditions
• Zuni and Hopi Cultural Scholarship — the western Pueblo communities whose 1680 participation is treated differently in the revolt literature
• New Mexico Archaeology Books — Bandelier, Hewett, and the archaeological tradition that provides pre-revolt Pueblo material context
• Comanche, Apache, and Plains Warfare Books — the raiding-and-alliance context that shaped Pueblo strategic calculations in 1680 and the 1692 reconquest era
• New Mexico Maps and Cartography — Miera y Pacheco's 1779 maps document the post-reconquista settlement geography shaped by the revolt's aftermath
• Penitente Brotherhood Books — the post-revolt Hispano religious tradition that emerged partly in response to the disruption of formal ecclesiastical structures
• New Mexico Land Grants Literature — the post-reconquista land-grant system whose terms were substantially shaped by the revolt's political consequences