A Manifesto • 12 Rights • NMLP Holds Itself to These • CC-BY 4.0
A Donor's Bill of Rights — Albuquerque
When you give books, clothing, furniture, or money to any organization in Albuquerque, you're owed something in return — not financially, but in honesty and respect. Twelve rights that any donation operator in this metro should be holding themselves to. NMLP is one of those operators; the standards apply to us as much as to anyone else.
Why this manifesto exists
There is no licensing board for donation operators in Albuquerque. There's no state-level consumer-protection regime for in-kind giving. There's no rating agency that publishes objective scores on how thrift stores, nonprofits, junk-removal services, or partner-pickup operations treat the people who give them things. The donor has to figure out the standard themselves, by reputation and by the long way — by getting burned, by hearing from friends, by reading a one-star Yelp review at the wrong moment.
That gap is bad for donors and it's also bad for the operators who do the work well, because the absence of a published standard makes it hard to distinguish them from operators who don't. So here's the standard I'd write if I had to write one. I'm Josh Eldred, the operator of NMLP, and I'm publishing this because I'd rather be measured against an explicit standard — including by donors who think NMLP is failing on one of these points — than be measured against nothing.
Twelve rights. Each one explained. None of them require legislation, none of them require a regulator, none of them require enforcement beyond donors voting with their phone calls. If every donation operator in Albuquerque held themselves to these standards, the ABQ donor experience would be substantially better than it currently is. If you're an operator reading this and you disagree with one of these points — say so. The standard improves through argument, not through silence.
Right 1
The right to know where your donation actually ends up.
If you give a book to a thrift store, you should be able to find out — by asking — what happens after the front-counter scan. Does it go on the retail floor? Is it bulk-sold to Savers per-pound? Is it shipped to a commercial textile recycler? Is the salable portion sold and the rejected portion landfilled? You shouldn't have to do investigative work to find out. The operator should be willing to explain the supply chain when asked.
NMLP standard: published the entire supply chain at the ABQ Book Donation Ecosystem Map, including the partner-nonprofit relationships, the Master Fibers paper-recycler observation, the salable-portion resale, the kids' book routing to APS Title I and family shelters, and the unsalvageable-to-recycling rule.
Right 2
The right to honest channel-fit advice, including "we're not the right channel for you."
If your situation fits a different operator's model better than the one you called, you should be told so. An operator that takes donations they can't actually use — because turning down volume feels like turning down support — is being dishonest in a way that costs you (in trash bills for the rejected portion) and costs the receiving organization (in sorting labor).
NMLP standard: the decision tool recommends channels other than NMLP when those channels fit better. The comparison pages explicitly say which donor situations favor which channel. Any phone call where NMLP isn't the right fit should end with us telling you who is.
Right 3
The right to refuse a "thrift-rejection pile" being silently landfilled at your expense.
When a thrift store takes your donation, sorts it, and sends the rejected portion to the dumpster without telling you, you've been billed for that disposal twice — once in your time and labor, once in the city tipping fee paid out of the donation revenue. Operators that quietly landfill their own intake should be willing to disclose what percentage of donations they retain versus discard, and where the discards go.
NMLP standard: we hand-sort everything that comes in. Salable adult books go to resale (which funds the operation). Useful children's books route to APS Title I, Little Free Libraries, family shelters, and refugee resettlement. Unsalvageable copies go to paper recycling, not landfill, by explicit policy. Documented at the ecosystem map.
Right 4
The right to a tax-deductible receipt at intake when the recipient is a 501(c)(3).
If the recipient is a 501(c)(3) public charity and you ask for a receipt, you should get one without friction. The receipt should include the date, the recipient's name and EIN, a description of items donated, and confirm that no goods or services were received in exchange. Operators that make this difficult — limiting receipts to specific hours, requiring a manager who's never available, refusing to itemize — are creating tax-deductibility friction for donors who deserve the deduction.
NMLP standard: NMLP is for-profit and doesn't issue tax-deductible receipts. We say so openly on every donor-facing page and route donors who need receipts to the 501(c)(3) channels documented in the tax-deductible donation map.
Right 5
The right to know how revenue is actually used.
501(c)(3) operators publish financial information on Form 990 (publicly available through GuideStar/Candid, CauseIQ, and ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer). For-profit operators don't have that obligation, but they should still be willing to explain the revenue flow when asked. "We're a thrift store" is not an explanation of where revenue goes. "Our revenue funds the youth mentoring match support staff" is.
NMLP standard: For-profit; revenue from the salable-adult-book resale funds the pickup operation, the warehouse, the truck, and the free hand-sort process that makes the children's-book routing to APS Title I + LFLs + family shelters possible. No external shareholders. Single-operator structure. Disclosed on every page.
Right 6
The right to drop off without your contact information being harvested.
When you drop off a donation, you should not be required to provide your phone number, email, or address as a condition of the operator accepting the donation. Contact information is sometimes useful (for receipts, for pickup scheduling, for one-time follow-up), but it should be optional, the operator should disclose what it'll be used for, and "sign up for our newsletter to give us your stuff" is not an acceptable barrier.
NMLP standard: 24/7 outdoor drop bin at 5445 Edith Blvd NE Unit A requires no contact information. For scheduled pickups, we ask for phone number and address only because we need them to come to your house; we don't add donors to a marketing list, and we don't share contact info with third parties.
Right 7
The right not to be lectured for what you're donating.
If you bring a bag of books, you should not get a sermon about their condition. If you bring a box of "trashy" paperbacks, you should not be told that you should have brought literary fiction. The operator's job is to handle what comes in, not to pass judgment on the donor's taste, organizational ability, or sorting effort. Donors who get lectured don't come back, and operators who lecture are signaling that they don't actually want the volume.
NMLP standard: we accept any condition without comment. The donor's job is to give them; our job is to sort them. The honest sorting outcomes are explained on the donor-facing pages (some go to schools, some go to resale, some go to recycling); the donor isn't responsible for those outcomes.
Right 8
The right to know when the operator is in a partnership or supply chain with another organization.
If a charity bulk-sells your donation to a for-profit thrift retailer under a partner-nonprofit per-pound arrangement, you should know that. If a junk-removal service is going to sell the salvageable portion downstream rather than disposing of it, you should know that. The supply chain isn't a secret; donors deserve to know the path their item takes.
NMLP standard: the ecosystem map publicly discloses the documented supply chains including the Savers Value Village partner-nonprofit relationships (BBBS-CNM and CHK), the Master Fibers paper-recycler observation, the Assistance League overflow-call relationship, and NMLP's role as end-of-chain buyer for Savers ABQ unsold book overflow. All of it is on the public record.
Right 9
The right to time-respect at pickup.
If a pickup is scheduled, it should happen within a reasonable window. "Sometime next week between 8 and 4" is not a window; it's a request for the donor to stay home for 40 hours. Pickup operators should commit to a specific day and a reasonable arrival range (most professional operators can offer a 2-4 hour window), and should call or text if running late. Donors are doing the operator a favor by giving them inventory; the operator should not be doing the donor a favor by showing up.
NMLP standard: scheduled pickups get a specific day, a reasonable arrival window, and a text update if we're running late. The donor's time is real; we don't burn it casually.
Right 10
The right to keep what's personal — letters, photos, family records — that's accidentally inside donations.
Donors regularly hand over books with letters tucked inside, photographs falling out, family Bibles with handwritten generations on the front flyleaf, or recipes folded between pages. These items belong to the donor's family, not to the receiving operator. The operator's responsibility is to find these items during sorting, hold them, and return them to the donor — or place them with an appropriate archive if the donor has explicitly released them. Operators that don't have a process for this are silently absorbing the donor's family records into their resale or recycling pipeline.
NMLP standard: hand-sorting catches loose items inside books as a routine part of the process. Letters, photographs, family records, and personal documents are pulled and held; the donor is contacted to return them. Items the donor explicitly wants placed archivally (genealogy binders, family Bibles, Manhattan Project material) are routed to the appropriate archive (Center for Southwest Research, NM Genealogical Society, Archdiocese of Santa Fe, NM Vietnam Veterans Memorial archive). The Field Guide to ABQ Estate Library Patterns documents the categories of personal material we routinely encounter.
Right 11
The right to honest pricing if the operator is buying.
If an operator is buying your books (used-bookstore buyback, online buyback service, antique dealer, estate buyer), the price offered should be defensible against the market value of what's being purchased. Lowball offers, "buy the collection for one price and resell at high margin" plays, and refusals to itemize the offer are all warning signs. The operator doesn't owe you retail price (they have legitimate margin requirements) but they should be willing to explain how the offer was derived and what the closest comp pricing looks like.
NMLP standard: NMLP rarely buys books (we operate primarily as a free-pickup donation channel). When we do — for unusual collections with significant collector value — we explain how the offer was derived. The honest framing of our buy-vs-donate position is documented at the SellBooksABQ sister site, which is structured as "I rarely buy + here's the honest answer + default is NMLP pickup."
Right 12
The right to a "we made a mistake" acknowledgment when the operator gets something wrong.
Every donation operator gets things wrong sometimes. Missed pickups happen. Receipts get lost. The pickup driver shows up at the wrong house. The wrong information gets posted on the operator's website. The honest standard is that when these things happen, the operator acknowledges the mistake, fixes what can be fixed, and takes the loss without trying to shift it onto the donor. Operators that deflect, gaslight, or refuse to acknowledge documented errors are operators you should not be using.
NMLP standard: when we get something wrong, we say so plainly, fix what we can fix, and take the loss. A recent example: the Read to Me Program comparison page included a misframing earlier in 2026 that was based on a misremembered detail from an in-person conversation. When the actual situation was clarified by program staff, the page was rewritten with an explicit correction note at the top acknowledging the earlier mistake. Corrections improve the operator's credibility, not damage it.
What to do with this Bill of Rights
If you're a donor: Use this as a checklist. Before you call an operator for a pickup, before you drop off a donation, before you choose between channels, ask whether the operator passes these twelve points. The ones that pass deserve your donations; the ones that don't deserve a phone call asking why not.
If you're an operator: Read it, push back on what you disagree with, write your own version, publish it. The standard improves through publication, not through silence. NMLP is publishing this because the absence of an explicit standard is bad for the donors and bad for the principled operators alike.
If you're a journalist, researcher, or regulator: This document is published under CC-BY 4.0 specifically so it can be cited, adapted, and used as the basis for evaluating donation operators. There's no licensing board for this work in Albuquerque; there should be at least a published standard.
Hold NMLP accountable
If NMLP fails to meet any of these twelve standards in your specific interaction with us — a missed pickup, a lecture you didn't deserve, a personal item that wasn't returned, a supply-chain disclosure that turned out to be incomplete, a contact-information handling issue, anything — I want to hear about it.
Call or text 702-496-4214. Email through the contact page. Leave a Google or Yelp review. Whatever channel works for you. The accountability mechanism for these standards is donor voice. Without it, the standards are aspirational; with it, they're operational.
I run this operation. The standards apply to me. The accountability is mine.
— Josh Eldred, NMLP. May 2026.
Related operating documents
- The ABQ Book Donation Ecosystem Map — full supply-chain disclosure
- Interactive "Where Should My Books Go?" Decision Tool
- ABQ Books in the Waste Stream — investigation
- Field Guide to ABQ Estate Library Patterns
- Tax-Deductible Book Donation Map
- Is NMLP Legit? Verification Page
- Contact NMLP
- About Josh Eldred + NMLP
Twelve Standards. One Phone Number.
NMLP holds itself to these twelve points and invites comparison with every other operator in the metro. Call or text 702-496-4214 to give us books, to ask a question, to push back on a point in this manifesto, or to report a failure.
Call or Text 702-496-4214Josh Eldred — NMLP — Free book pickup across the Albuquerque metro.