Pillar · New Mexico Regional Reference
New Mexico Fiestas, Indian Market, Spanish Market & Cultural Festivals — Book & Ephemera Collecting
Santa Fe Indian Market (SWAIA, 1922–present) · Spanish Market (SCAS, 1926–present) · Santa Fe Fiesta (1712, oldest US community celebration) · Gallup Inter-Tribal Ceremonial (1922–present) · Zozobra (Will Shuster, 1926) · The Entrada controversy · Matachines dances · Las Posadas · Taos Pueblo Feast Days · Zuni Shalako. Wilson’s Myth of Santa Fe (UNM Press, 1997), Weigle & Fiore, Mullin, Babcock, Rodriguez. SWAIA catalog and Gallup program runs from 1922 to the present. The complete literary and ephemera landscape of New Mexico’s festival and cultural-market tradition, mapped for the book collector and regional researcher.
Last verified May 2026 · Original research by Josh Eldred
The invention of Santa Fe: why this festival landscape requires a collecting guide
Fiestas & Indian Market books, including The Myth of Santa Fe: Creating a Modern Regional Tradition (1997), are sought-after collectibles commanding premium. There is no city in the United States where the relationship between cultural festivals, the art market, civic identity, and real estate value has been more deliberately engineered than Santa Fe, New Mexico. Between roughly 1910 and 1940, a small coalition of Anglo archaeologists, artists, museum administrators, Chamber of Commerce boosters, and railroad publicists made a series of decisions that transformed Santa Fe from a declining territorial capital—dusty, economically marginal, largely ignored by the national press—into the most recognizable cultural brand in the American Southwest. The Indian Market, the Spanish Market, the Fiesta, the Zozobra burning, the adobe architectural codes, the “Old Santa Fe Style,” and the festival calendar that draws hundreds of thousands of visitors to a city of 85,000 residents each year: all of these are the artifacts of a managed place-making project that has few parallels in American urban history.
This is also, consequently, one of the most richly documented cultural processes in American regional history. The books, catalogs, programs, posters, pamphlets, and promotional ephemera generated by New Mexico’s festival culture constitute a collecting category of genuine depth and historical significance. The SWAIA Indian Market has published official catalogs and award publications continuously since 1922, creating a run of over a century of primary documentation. The Gallup Inter-Tribal Indian Ceremonial program series runs to equal length. The Santa Fe Fiesta has generated programs, pageant scripts, commemorative publications, and controversy literature for three centuries. The Spanish Colonial Arts Society has produced exhibition catalogs and promotional material since 1926. And the scholarly literature analyzing all of this—from architectural history to anthropology, from gender studies to art market economics—is substantial enough to constitute its own sub-library.
This pillar maps the complete landscape: the key events and institutions, the scholarly books that analyze them, the ephemera that documents them year by year, and the collector market for each category. It is part of the reference infrastructure NMLP is building to ensure that regionally significant materials are recognized and preserved rather than lost when they surface in donation streams. A 1920s SWAIA Indian Market catalog is not a brochure; it is a primary source for the history of Native American art markets and cultural tourism in twentieth-century America. A 1930s Gallup Ceremonial program is not a flyer; it is one of a small surviving number of documents from the founding decade of the most important inter-tribal cultural gathering in the United States. This guide exists so that these materials are recognized for what they are.
Edgar Lee Hewett and the Museum of New Mexico: the institutional foundation
Edgar Lee Hewett (1865–1946) was the single most influential figure in the creation of New Mexico’s cultural identity as a modern tourist and arts destination, and understanding his role is essential to understanding every festival and market this pillar covers. Hewett was an archaeologist, institution builder, and cultural entrepreneur of extraordinary energy and ambition. He founded or co-founded the Museum of New Mexico (1909), the School of American Archaeology (now the School for Advanced Research, 1907), the Archaeological Institute of America’s Southwest program, and the Santa Fe art colony infrastructure. He was involved in the passage of the Antiquities Act (1906), the creation of the National Park Service’s archaeological program, and the development of the Palace of the Governors as a museum. He was also a relentless self-promoter, an effective political operator, and a man whose relationship with Native peoples was complex, paternalistic, and ultimately extractive in ways that later generations have documented in detail.
Hewett’s key insight—which he acted on with unusual clarity and consistency—was that New Mexico’s economic future lay in the exploitation of its unique cultural resources: the Pueblo peoples and their living craft traditions, the Spanish Colonial heritage and its visual culture, and the landscape that provided the setting for both. He worked to create institutions that would attract artists and scholars to Santa Fe, develop an art market for Native and Hispanic crafts, and build the festival infrastructure that would draw tourists. The Indian Market, the Fiesta, and the broader arts economy of Santa Fe are his legacies as much as any individual’s.
Hewett in the collecting literature
Edgar Lee Hewett did not produce a major book about Santa Fe’s festival culture, but he wrote extensively about the archaeological and cultural landscape of New Mexico. His Ancient Life in the American Southwest (Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, 1930) is the most collected of his books, trading the common reading copy to mid-range zone for the 1930 Bobbs-Merrill first edition. His contributions to the Art and Archaeology journal (which he founded) and to El Palacio (the Museum of New Mexico’s bulletin, which he also founded) are primary sources for the early festival and market history; complete runs of these periodicals from the 1910s and 1920s are significant institutional research tools. The biographical literature on Hewett includes Beatrice Chauvenet’s Hewett and Friends: A Biography of Santa Fe’s Vibrant Era (Museum of New Mexico Press, 1983), which trades common reading copy range. For the critical analysis of Hewett’s cultural politics, Chris Wilson’s Myth of Santa Fe is the essential source.
The Fred Harvey Company and the railroad market
The Santa Fe Railway and its hospitality concessionaire, the Fred Harvey Company, were the other half of the institutional foundation that made New Mexico’s cultural economy possible. The railway brought tourists to New Mexico; the Harvey Houses and Harvey gift shops created the infrastructure for selling Native American arts and crafts to them. The Fred Harvey Company employed Native American artisans, commissioned reproductions of traditional designs, and developed what critics have described as the first systematized machine for the commercial exploitation of Native American cultural production—and what defenders have described as one of the most important mechanisms for the economic survival of Pueblo craft traditions during a period of severe economic pressure on Pueblo communities.
The Harvey Company’s role in shaping the market for Southwest Native arts intersects directly with the Indian Market’s founding and with the development of quality standards and authenticity certification that SWAIA eventually institutionalized. The Harvey buyers—particularly Herman Schweizer, who managed the Harvey curio department for decades—were among the first to distinguish “authentic” from “tourist-grade” Native production and to pay premium prices for quality, a distinction that SWAIA would later systematize into its jurying process.
Inventing the Southwest: The Fred Harvey Company and Native American Art, by Kathleen L. Howard and Diana F. Pardue (Flagstaff: Northland Publishing; Phoenix: Heard Museum, 1996). This catalog of a major Heard Museum exhibition provides the most accessible scholarly treatment of the Harvey Company’s role in the Southwest Native arts market. It covers the Harvey Indian Department, Herman Schweizer, the Hopi House at the Grand Canyon, the curio trade, and the development of authenticity standards. The book is amply illustrated with photographs of Harvey stores, artisans, and tourist encounters. Published simultaneously in hardcover (the Heard Museum catalog edition) and trade paperback.
Collector market: The 1996 Northland/Heard hardcover first edition in Fine dust jacket trades solid mid-range collectible value. The trade paperback is the more common form and trades common reading copy range. Both editions are becoming harder to find in Fine condition as the title ages out of active circulation. A related title: Marta Weigle and Barbara A. Babcock, eds., The Great Southwest of the Fred Harvey Company and the Santa Fe Railway (Phoenix: Heard Museum, 1996), trades solid mid-range collectible value for the hardcover edition.
Chris Wilson and The Myth of Santa Fe (1997)
Chris Wilson is a professor of cultural landscape preservation at the University of New Mexico School of Architecture and Planning and the author of the most important single book about Santa Fe’s constructed identity. The Myth of Santa Fe: Creating a Modern Regional Tradition (University of New Mexico Press, 1997) is a work of architectural and cultural history that traces how Santa Fe’s distinctive visual and cultural character was not an organic survival of an ancient tradition but a deliberate invention, constructed between roughly 1912 and 1940 by a coalition of boosters, artists, archaeologists, and civic promoters who believed—correctly—that the city’s economic future lay in becoming a destination for cultural tourism.
Wilson’s argument operates on multiple levels simultaneously. Architecturally, he traces how the “Old Santa Fe Style”—the mandatory adobe and Pueblo Revival building form that defines the city’s visual identity today—was a 1910s invention rather than a survival of Spanish Colonial or Pueblo building practice. Many of the buildings most tourists regard as “authentic” Spanish Colonial or Pueblo Revival structures are early twentieth-century constructions or reconstructions that deliberately evoked an imagined indigenous past. Culturally, he traces how the Indian Market, the Spanish Market, the Fiesta, and the broader arts economy were all coordinated elements of a place-making project that benefited the Anglo arts community and the city’s business interests in ways that were not always aligned with the interests of the Pueblo and Hispano communities whose cultural heritage was being marketed.
The Myth of Santa Fe: Creating a Modern Regional Tradition, by Chris Wilson (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1997). 403 pages, illustrated with black-and-white photographs and architectural drawings. The book covers the Old Santa Fe Style and its invention; the role of Hewett, the Museum of New Mexico, and the School of American Archaeology; the Indian Market and Spanish Market and their founding ideology; the Fiesta and Zozobra; the artist colony and its relationship to the cultural marketing project; and the relationship between the invented tradition and contemporary Santa Fe identity politics.
Points of issue for the first edition: University of New Mexico Press, 1997. Issued simultaneously in hardcover (ISBN 0-8263-1745-7) and trade paperback (ISBN 0-8263-1746-5). The hardcover first edition has “First edition” on the copyright page with no additional printing history; the copyright page reads “Copyright © 1997 by the University of New Mexico Press.” The dust jacket features a period photograph of a Santa Fe street scene. Later paperback printings (there have been multiple) carry printing history on the copyright page. The hardcover edition is substantially rarer than the paperback and commands a significant premium.
Collector market: Hardcover first edition in Fine/Fine condition: solid mid-range collectible value. Hardcover in Very Good condition with price-clipped or worn jacket: solid mid-range collectible value. Trade paperback first edition: the common reading copy to mid-range zone. Later paperback printings: common reading copy range. A presentation copy signed by Wilson — who has been a prominent figure in New Mexico cultural heritage circles and signs books at lectures and conferences — would trade respectable collectible value for a hardcover, solid mid-range collectible value for a paperback.
Found old books in an estate or attic? Text me a photo at 702-496-4214 and I'll tell you what I see.
Santa Fe Indian Market: SWAIA and the catalog run (1922–present)
The Southwestern Association for Indian Arts (SWAIA) was founded in 1922 to organize what was initially called the Indian Fair—an annual gathering of Native American artists at the Santa Fe Plaza to display and sell their work, with prizes and awards judged by arts professionals. The event has grown over a century into the largest Native American arts market in the world: the current Indian Market draws approximately 1,200 artists from more than 220 tribes, attracts over 100,000 visitors over its two-day August weekend, and generates in excess of a hundred million dollars in annual economic impact for the Santa Fe region.
SWAIA’s institutional history is inextricable from the history of the Native American arts market as a whole. The organization created and enforced the authenticity standards—hand-made, tribally enrolled artist, no machine production—that distinguish Indian Market work from tourist-grade imports, and these standards became the model for authenticity certification across the Southwest arts market. The Indian Arts and Crafts Act of 1935 and its 1990 successor both drew on the standards that SWAIA had been enforcing for decades. The organization also developed the prize and award system that identifies master artists and emerging talent, creating a reputational infrastructure that has shaped careers and established market prices for generations of Native artists.
The SWAIA catalog and award book run (1922–present) is the most significant festival ephemera series in the Southwest collecting category. SWAIA has published official programs, award catalogs, and market guides continuously since the founding year, creating a run that now spans over a century. These publications vary considerably in format across the decades: early issues are typically small, simply printed programs with artist listings, prize winners, and vendor information; later issues grew into substantial production catalogs with artist biographies, color photographs, and essays. The most recent SWAIA publications (2000s–present) are professionally produced full-color catalogs that function both as market guides and as collector’s reference tools.
Collecting the run — tier structure:
1922–1940 (early issues, extreme scarcity): True 1920s SWAIA programs are among the rarest pieces of New Mexico festival ephemera. Most surviving copies are in institutional collections; privately held examples appear at auction and in specialist dealers perhaps once or twice a decade. Condition ranges from Very Good (exceptional) to Poor (typical); even worn and incomplete copies are significant finds. Collector value: serious collector territory per issue for 1920s programs in any readable condition; Fine examples would trade higher. 1930s issues trade respectable collectible value.
1940s–1960s (scarce, intermittent survival): Issues from the immediate postwar period begin to appear more regularly in the market, though institutional copies predominate. Trade range: the mid-range collectible zone per issue depending on condition and decade.
1970s–1990s (uncommon but findable): The era when SWAIA publications expanded significantly. The 50th anniversary (1972) and 75th anniversary (1997) publications are particularly significant. Trade range: the common reading copy to mid-range zone per issue.
2000s–present (readily available): Current and recent SWAIA publications available new from SWAIA; used copies common. Trade range: common reading copy range.
Special SWAIA publications: SWAIA has also published monographs on specific artists and art forms, master artist tributes, and exhibition catalogs for the annual Invitational that runs alongside Indian Market. These vary widely in format and value; major artist monographs by significant Native artists trade the mid-range to upper collectible zone depending on the artist and printing.
The scholarly literature on Indian Market specifically includes Bruce Bernstein and W. Jackson Rushing’s Modern by Tradition: American Indian Painting in the Studio Style (Museum of New Mexico Press, 1995), which connects the Indian Market to the development of the “Studio Style” of Native American painting that The Studio at the Santa Fe Indian School codified during the 1930s. The book trades solid mid-range collectible value for the Museum of NM Press first edition. Molly Mullin’s Culture in the Marketplace (discussed in detail below) provides the analytical framework. J.J. Brody’s Indian Painters and White Patrons (University of New Mexico Press, 1971) is the earlier and still-essential study of the market relationship between Native artists and Anglo collectors; the 1971 UNM Press first edition trades the mid-range collectible zone.
Molly Mullin: Culture in the Marketplace (Duke University Press, 2001)
Molly Mullin’s Culture in the Marketplace: Gender, Art, and Value in the American Southwest (Durham: Duke University Press, 2001) is the most analytically rigorous study of what the Santa Fe art markets actually do. Working from anthropological fieldwork conducted during the 1990s, Mullin examines how the markets assign value to Native American and Hispanic arts, how gender shapes both the production of art and its reception by collectors and critics, and how the system of cultural brokerage established in the 1920s has evolved while maintaining its fundamental structure: Anglo collectors and dealers mediating the relationship between Native and Hispanic producers and the national art market.
Mullin’s specific contribution is her analysis of how authenticity is constructed and maintained in the market context. The Indian Market’s authenticity standards—hand-made, tribally enrolled artist, traditional materials where applicable—are not natural categories but institutional constructions that encode particular assumptions about what “authentic” Native art is, which tribes and traditions count as authentic sources, and who has the authority to certify authenticity. Her examination of the gender dynamics of the market is equally revealing: female potters and weavers occupy a different position in the market than male painters and jewelers, and the gendered hierarchy of media within the Indian Market (with painting and jewelry commanding higher prices than pottery and textiles in many market segments) reflects assumptions about art and craft that have little to do with technical difficulty or cultural significance.
Culture in the Marketplace: Gender, Art, and Value in the American Southwest, by Molly H. Mullin (Durham and London: Duke University Press, 2001). 260 pages. Published simultaneously in hardcover and trade paperback.
Collector market: Duke University Press hardcover first edition in Fine/Fine dust jacket: solid mid-range collectible value. Trade paperback first edition: the common reading copy to mid-range zone. The paperback is the standard scholarly form and the more commonly encountered edition. The book is not widely available in the used market despite its importance—its academic audience tends to hold their copies—which keeps prices higher than its academic press origin would suggest. A presentation copy signed by Mullin would be a significant find for this collecting category, as she published relatively little and the book represents years of fieldwork.
Barbara Babcock and Inventing the Southwest
Barbara A. Babcock (1943–2012) was a professor of English and comparative cultural and literary studies at the University of Arizona whose work on the Southwest focused on the representation of Native and Hispanic culture in tourist art, museum display, and popular imagery. Her most directly relevant contribution to this collecting category is her essay work collected in and around the major Heard Museum catalog project. The exhibition Inventing the Southwest: The Fred Harvey Company and Native American Art (Heard Museum, 1996) drew on Babcock’s theoretical framework for analyzing how the Harvey Company and the railroad tourist infrastructure participated in the construction of Southwest Native identity for an Anglo audience.
Babcock’s essay “A Tolerated Margin of Mess: The Trickster and His Tales Reconsidered” and her broader analysis of Southwestern cultural tourism are scattered across academic journals and edited volumes that are not commonly encountered in the general used book market. Collectors interested in her work should search specifically for The Pueblo Storyteller: Development of a Figurative Ceramic Tradition (University of Arizona Press, 1986, with Guy and Doris Monthan), which is her most collected book-length work: it documents the development of the Pueblo storyteller figurine tradition, traces the role of Helen Cordero (the Cochiti potter who invented the storyteller form in 1964) and her successors, and analyzes the market dynamics that transformed a traditional figurative form into one of the most commercially successful genres in contemporary Pueblo art. The 1986 University of Arizona Press first edition trades solid mid-range collectible value.
Spanish Colonial Arts Society and Spanish Market (1925/1926–present)
The Spanish Colonial Arts Society (SCAS) was established in 1925 by the artist and preservationist Frank Applegate and the writer and cultural activist Mary Austin, motivated by their observation that the traditional Spanish Colonial crafts of New Mexico—particularly the santos and bultos of the santero tradition, the colcha embroidery, the Rio Grande blanket weaving, and the tinwork and furniture-making—were disappearing as the cash economy penetrated rural Hispanic communities. The first Spanish Market was held in 1926 as a showcase and sales venue for these traditional arts.
The SCAS revival project occupies an uncomfortable position in the history of cultural preservation. On one hand, it genuinely preserved craft skills that would otherwise have been lost: the organization documented traditional designs and techniques, trained younger artisans, created a market that provided economic incentive to continue traditional production, and built an institutional framework that eventually included the collections now housed at the Museum of New Mexico. On the other hand, the revival was organized and led by Anglo cultural brokers who defined what counted as “authentic” Spanish Colonial art, which designs were “traditional” and which were not, and who qualified as legitimate traditional artisans—in ways that sometimes reflected Anglo aesthetic preferences more than the actual continuities of Hispanic craft tradition.
Spanish Colonial Arts Society exhibition catalogs and publications (1926–present) constitute the primary documentary record of the Spanish Market tradition. Early SCAS publications from the 1926–1950 period are among the rarest pieces of New Mexico cultural ephemera. The Society was small, its publications were produced in limited quantities for a regional audience, and few copies were preserved by either institutions or private collectors. Surviving early SCAS catalogs—particularly issues from the founding decade (1926–1935)—are significant primary sources for the history of the Spanish Colonial arts revival and for the development of the market for Hispanic traditional arts.
Tier structure:
1926–1940: Extremely scarce. True founding-era SCAS publications rarely surface outside institutional collections. Collector value: respectable collectible value per item in any readable condition.
1941–1970: Scarce. Occasional appearances in specialist catalogs. Collector value: the mid-range collectible zone per item.
1971–2000: Uncommon. The Society’s publications expanded in this period. Trade range: the mid-range collectible zone.
2001–present: Readily available from SCAS. Trade range: common reading copy range.
Related scholarship: The most useful analytical treatment of the SCAS revival and Spanish Market is Charles Briggs’s The Wood Carvers of Córdova, New Mexico: Social Dimensions of an Artistic ‘Revival’ (Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1980, reprinted by the School of American Research Press, 1991 under the title The Wood Carvers of Córdova). Briggs examines the woodcarving revival at Córdova, NM—a village that became particularly associated with the santos revival—and analyzes the social and economic dynamics that the revival created. The 1980 UTPress first edition trades solid mid-range collectible value; the 1991 SAR Press reprint trades the common reading copy to mid-range zone.
Not sure whether to sell, donate, or keep? Call or text me at 702-496-4214 — I'll walk you through it.
Santa Fe Fiesta (since 1712): the oldest community celebration in the United States
The Santa Fe Fiesta originated in 1712 as a Catholic civic celebration commemorating Don Diego de Vargas’s 1692 reconquest of Santa Fe from the Pueblo peoples who had expelled the Spanish in the Pueblo Revolt of 1680. As such, it is simultaneously the oldest continuously celebrated community festival in the United States and one of the most politically charged: a festival whose founding narrative celebrates the colonial re-imposition of Spanish rule over Pueblo peoples who had successfully revolted against that rule. The Fiesta has been periodically suppressed and revived over its three centuries; the version celebrated in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries was substantially reconstructed in the early 1900s as part of the same place-making project that created the Indian Market and the Spanish Market.
The modern Fiesta consists of multiple distinct components: the religious procession of La Conquistadora (a small wooden statue of the Virgin Mary that Vargas brought back to Santa Fe), the Burning of Zozobra (added by Will Shuster in 1926), the Entrada pageant (a theatrical re-enactment of Vargas’s reconquest, which was the center of the Fiesta’s civic program for most of the twentieth century and became the focus of major controversy beginning in the 2010s), Las Posadas (the processional re-enactment of Mary and Joseph’s search for lodging), the Matachines dances (a hybrid European-indigenous ceremonial dance tradition found throughout northern New Mexico, closely connected to the Hispano music and folk song tradition), and the general carnival atmosphere of the Fiesta marketplace on the Santa Fe Plaza.
The Entrada controversy in brief
The Entrada pageant re-enacted Don Diego de Vargas’s 1692 reconquest of Santa Fe, complete with costumed participants representing the Spanish colonizers and, in some versions, Pueblo peoples in submission. Pueblo communities—particularly Ohkay Owingeh (formerly San Juan Pueblo), which was directly involved in the original reconquest and regarded the pageant as a celebration of colonial violence against their ancestors—had objected to the Entrada for decades. In 2015–2018, these objections became sustained public protests with broad coalition support. After intense negotiation between the Fiesta Council, the City of Santa Fe, Pueblo communities, and Hispano cultural organizations, the traditional Entrada march was discontinued in 2018. The controversy produced an extensive documentary record: newspaper archives, public statements by Pueblo governments and Hispano cultural organizations, academic commentary, and a debate about the relationship between cultural heritage, civic identity, and historical accountability that has not been fully resolved. Collectors interested in primary documentation of the Entrada controversy should look for the Santa Fe New Mexican newspaper archives from 2015–2018 and the published statements of Pueblo governors and the Fiesta Council.
Santa Fe Fiesta programs (1920s–present): The modern Fiesta’s paper program series begins in the early twentieth century, when the reconstructed Fiesta was producing printed programs for the Entrada pageant and associated events. Early programs (1920s–1940s) are scarce and significant: they typically include the Entrada pageant script, cast lists, historical essays about Vargas and the reconquest, and advertising from Santa Fe businesses. These early programs are primary sources for the history of the invented Fiesta tradition and for the developing narrative of the reconquest’s significance to Santa Fe civic identity.
Tier structure:
1920s–1940s: Scarce. True pre-war Fiesta programs in readable condition trade the mid-range to upper collectible zone.
1950s–1970s: Uncommon. Trade range: the mid-range collectible zone.
1980s–present: Readily available. Trade range: common reading copy range.
Special Entrada documentation (2015–2018 controversy period): Programs, protest materials, and printed ephemera from the Entrada controversy period are not yet collected systematically but have historical significance that will increase over time.
Scholarly treatments: The most useful book-length treatment of the Fiesta and its politics is Andrew Leo Lovato’s Santa Fe Hispanic Culture: Preserving Identity in a Tourist Town (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 2004), which examines the conflict between Hispano cultural identity politics and the tourist economy’s demands. The 2004 UNM Press paperback trades common reading copy range.
Zozobra and Will Shuster (1926–present)
Will Shuster (1893–1969) arrived in Santa Fe in 1920, part of the wave of health-seekers—tuberculosis patients who came to the Southwest seeking the dry climate that promised relief—who transformed the demographics and cultural life of the city in the early twentieth century. Unlike most health-seekers, Shuster stayed, became a painter, and became a central figure in the Santa Fe art scene for the next half century. In 1921 he joined with four other young painters to form Los Cinco Pintores (The Five Painters)—Josef Bakos, Fremont Ellis, Walter Mruk, Willard Nash, and Shuster—a group that mounted the first exhibition of modernist painting in Santa Fe and challenged the more conservative aesthetics of the established Taos Society of Artists.
Shuster’s most enduring creation was not a painting but a ritual. In 1926 he built the first Zozobra for the Santa Fe Fiesta: a giant puppet figure, roughly twelve feet tall, representing “Old Man Gloom”—the worries, failures, and bad memories of the past year. The figure was stuffed with shredded paper (later with letters, divorce papers, police reports, and anything else citizens wanted to symbolically destroy), set up in Fort Marcy Park, and burned to the accompaniment of a crowd chanting “Burn him!” Shuster modeled the Zozobra ritual on his knowledge of Yaqui fire ceremonies and Pueblo ritual practice, creating a hybrid performance that was simultaneously a pagan bonfire, a Catholic exorcism, and a piece of civic theater. He donated the tradition to the Kiwanis Club of Santa Fe in 1964, and the Kiwanis have managed it ever since. The current Zozobra stands fifty feet tall, draws crowds of 50,000, and remains one of the most visually spectacular events in the American Southwest.
Collecting Will Shuster
The primary book-length treatment of Shuster is Joseph Dispenza and Louise Turner’s Will Shuster: A Santa Fe Legend (Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico Press, 1989). This exhibition catalog and biographical study documents Shuster’s painting career, his role in Los Cinco Pintores, his friendship with the Santa Fe art colony, and his creation of Zozobra. The Museum of New Mexico Press first edition (1989) in Fine condition with dust jacket trades solid mid-range collectible value; copies without jackets trade common reading copy range. The book is increasingly difficult to find in Fine condition as it ages out of general circulation.
Los Cinco Pintores exhibition catalogs are also collected. The group exhibited together and separately throughout the 1920s and 1930s, and surviving catalogs from their early shows are significant primary sources for the development of Santa Fe modernism. Any pre-1940 Los Cinco Pintores or Will Shuster exhibition catalog would be a significant find.
Gallup Inter-Tribal Indian Ceremonial (1922–present)
The Gallup Inter-Tribal Indian Ceremonial, held annually since 1922 in Gallup, New Mexico, is one of the oldest and largest inter-tribal gatherings in the United States. Founded the same year as the Santa Fe Indian Market, the Ceremonial developed along different lines: where the Indian Market focused primarily on the visual arts (jewelry, pottery, weaving, painting), the Ceremonial centered on dance performances, rodeo, and a major arts-and-crafts trade show. At its peak in the mid-twentieth century, the Ceremonial drew tribal participants from hundreds of nations across North America and attracted crowds of over 50,000 to what was, for many of its decades, the most visible showcase of Native American cultural performance accessible to non-Native audiences.
The Ceremonial’s relationship with the tribes it represented has been complex and often contested. The event was organized by the non-Native business community of Gallup, which had obvious economic interests in the tourist traffic it generated; tribal communities participated on terms that varied considerably over the decades, from enthusiastic engagement to boycott and critique. The Ceremonial was criticized at various points for its commercialism, for its representation of Native culture as entertainment for Anglo tourists, and for the conditions it imposed on tribal participants. At the same time, it provided income, visibility, and a platform for intertribal networking that many participants valued. The complicated history of the Ceremonial mirrors in miniature the broader story of Native American cultural tourism in the twentieth-century Southwest.
Gallup Inter-Tribal Indian Ceremonial programs (1922–present) constitute the most significant surviving documentary record of the event. Annual programs typically include the schedule of dance performances and rodeo events, tribal participant lists, trade fair vendor information, photographs of dancers and ceremonial regalia, historical essays about the event, and extensive advertising from Gallup businesses and regional enterprises. Early programs are invaluable primary sources: the 1920s programs document the founding of the Ceremonial and the participating tribes; the 1930s programs capture the event during its Route 66 heyday; the 1940s programs document wartime participation and the changes the war brought to the inter-tribal community.
Tier structure:
1922–1935 (founding era, extreme scarcity): True early-1920s Gallup Ceremonial programs are among the rarest pieces of New Mexico regional ephemera. They were printed in limited quantities for a regional event that had not yet achieved national tourist significance, were handled and discarded by attendees, and were not systematically preserved by either tribal or civic institutions. Collector value: upper mid-range collectible value per issue for 1920s programs in any readable condition. 1930s issues: respectable collectible value.
1936–1960: Scarce but occasionally surfacing. Route 66 increased the Ceremonial’s profile and may have improved survival rates for programs from this period. Trade range: the mid-range collectible zone.
1961–1990: Uncommon. Trade range: the common reading copy to mid-range zone.
1991–present: More readily available. Trade range: common reading copy range.
Institutional holdings: The Gallup Public Library, the Gallup Chamber of Commerce archive, and the New Mexico State Records Center and Archives hold the most substantial institutional collections of Ceremonial programs, though their runs are not complete. The Smithsonian Institution’s National Anthropological Archives has some documentation. Private collectors have assembled near-complete runs of post-1960 programs; complete runs from 1922 to the present are, as far as is known, nonexistent.
The Matachines Dance: Sylvia Rodriguez (UNM Press, 1996)
The Matachines is a ceremonial dance tradition found throughout the Río Grande Pueblo communities and the Hispanic villages of northern New Mexico, performed at feast days, Christmas, and other ceremonial occasions. Its origin is contested: the dance has European roots in a Moorish combat drama that the Spanish brought to the Americas, but in New Mexico it has been thoroughly transformed by two or three centuries of adaptation within both Pueblo and Hispanic contexts, producing local versions that vary significantly from community to community while sharing certain structural features: masked characters including the Monarca, the Malinche (a young girl whose role is central to the drama), the Abuelos (grandfathers who serve as clowns), and bull-headed figures representing indigenous power.
Sylvia Rodriguez’s The Matachines Dance: Ritual Symbolism and Interethnic Relations in the Upper Rio Grande Valley (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1996; revised paperback, 1996) is the definitive scholarly treatment. Rodriguez, a professor of anthropology at UNM who grew up in Taos, brings both academic training and insider knowledge to her analysis. The book documents the Matachines as performed in six communities—Taos Pueblo, Alcalde, Arroyo Seco, San Juan Pueblo, Jémez Pueblo, and Bernalillo—and analyzes the dance’s symbolic content, its contested meanings for performers and audiences, and its role in the ongoing negotiation of identity and interethnic relations in northern New Mexico.
The Matachines Dance: Ritual Symbolism and Interethnic Relations in the Upper Rio Grande Valley, by Sylvia Rodriguez (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1996; revised paperback edition, 1996). 198 pages, with photographs and musical notation.
Collector market: The 1996 UNM Press cloth first edition in Fine dust jacket trades solid mid-range collectible value. The 1996 paperback first edition trades the common reading copy to mid-range zone. The 2009 revised paperback, which includes a new preface, is the current standard edition and trades common reading copy range new or used. A presentation copy signed by Rodriguez — who is a central figure in New Mexico cultural anthropology and signs books at academic events — would trade solid mid-range collectible value.
Have books you're ready to part with? I offer free pickup across Albuquerque — call 702-496-4214.
Weigle & Fiore: Santa Fe and Taos: The Writer’s Era (Ancient City Press, 1982)
Marta Weigle has been one of the central figures in the documentation and analysis of New Mexico’s cultural landscape for over four decades, producing a body of work in folklore, literary history, and cultural geography that has no peer in the field. With Kyle Fiore, she edited Santa Fe and Taos: The Writer’s Era, 1916–1941 (Santa Fe: Ancient City Press, 1982), an anthology of primary sources and documentary essays covering the literary and artistic colonization of northern New Mexico by the Anglo writer-artist communities that established themselves in Santa Fe and Taos during and after World War I.
The volume’s relevance to the festival collecting category is direct: the writer-artists of the 1916–1941 era were simultaneously the audience for and the promoters of the emerging festival culture. Mary Austin, Witter Bynner, Haniel Long, D.H. Lawrence, Mabel Dodge Luhan, Elsie Clews Parsons, Oliver La Farge—all of the figures represented in the Weigle-Fiore anthology were present at the founding of the Indian Market and the Spanish Market, wrote about them, collected from them, and contributed to the ideological framework that made them culturally significant. The volume thus serves as the primary literary documentation of the cultural milieu in which the festival institutions were born.
Santa Fe and Taos: The Writer’s Era, 1916–1941, edited by Marta Weigle and Kyle Fiore (Santa Fe: Ancient City Press, 1982). 234 pages, illustrated with period photographs.
Points of issue: Ancient City Press, Santa Fe, New Mexico, 1982. Issued in cloth with dust jacket and in trade paperback. The cloth edition is the more collectible form; the trade paperback was the more widely distributed. The Ancient City Press is a small regional press that has produced significant New Mexico regional titles since the 1970s; its first editions in good condition are steadily increasing in value as the press’s regional significance becomes clearer.
Collector market: Cloth first edition in Fine/Fine condition: solid mid-range collectible value. Trade paperback first edition: the common reading copy to mid-range zone. The book has not been reprinted and is becoming genuinely difficult to find in Fine condition; Very Good copies are more typical in the market. Presentation copies signed by Weigle would trade solid mid-range collectible value.
Other festivals: Taos Pueblo Feast Days, Zuni Shalako, Albuquerque Balloon Fiesta
New Mexico’s festival calendar extends well beyond Santa Fe’s managed cultural economy. The Taos Pueblo Feast Days—particularly the San Geronimo Feast Day (September 30) and the various winter dances—are among the most visually spectacular ceremonial events in North America, drawing photographers, artists, and visitors who have been documenting them since the late nineteenth century. The photographic and artistic literature on Taos Pueblo feast days is substantial: it overlaps with the broader Taos art colony literature and with the ethnographic literature on Taos Pueblo, and it raises the same cultural sensitivity issues that attend the photography and documentation of any restricted ceremonial event. Ansel Adams’s Taos Pueblo photographs (published as the portfolio Taos Pueblo in 1930, with text by Mary Austin) are among the most collectible items in this category; the 1930 Grabhorn Press first edition of twelve copies is one of the most valuable American artist’s books of the twentieth century.
The Zuni Shalako ceremony has been documented in the ethnographic literature since Cushing and Stevenson (see the NMLP Zuni Pueblo pillar for detailed treatment), but it also figures in the festival collecting category because of the tourism literature it generated: Shalako attracted outside visitors from the early twentieth century, was described in travel writing and popular journalism, and was the subject of both photographic documentation and controversy about outside access to restricted ceremony. The Shalako documentation in the festival ephemera category is minimal; most of the significant material is in the ethnographic literature.
The Albuquerque International Balloon Fiesta, held each October since 1972, is New Mexico’s largest annual event by attendance, drawing over 800,000 visitors and hundreds of hot air balloons from around the world. Its collecting literature is primarily photographic: coffee-table books documenting the balloons, the mass ascensions, and the landscape are widely available. This category is not a primary focus for the serious regional book collector, but signed limited-edition balloon photography books by major landscape photographers with New Mexico connections can trade the mid-range collectible zone.
Las Posadas, Los Pastores, and the Hispanic folk drama tradition
The Hispanic folk drama tradition of New Mexico includes Las Posadas (the procession re-enacting Mary and Joseph’s search for lodging, performed during the nine nights before Christmas), Los Pastores (the shepherds’ play, a colonial-era religious drama performed at Christmas), and the Los Reyes Magos (Epiphany celebrations). These traditions are performed throughout northern New Mexico communities and at festival events in Santa Fe, Albuquerque, and Taos, and they represent a folk theater tradition with four-century roots in New Mexico’s colonial history.
The collecting literature on Hispanic folk drama overlaps with the broader Spanish Colonial cultural literature and with the work of Juan B. Rael, whose The Sources and Diffusion of the Mexican Shepherds’ Plays (Guadalajara: Librería La Joyita, 1965) is a primary scholarly reference. The broader context is provided by the NMLP pillar on New Mexico Hispano Theater and Folk Drama Books. For the festival collecting category, the most relevant materials are the performance scripts, programs, and ephemera generated by specific Las Posadas productions, particularly those associated with the Santa Fe Fiesta or with major church or community organizations. Pre-1950 performance scripts and programs are rare and historically significant.
Eli Levin’s Santa Fe Bohemia and the later art colony literature
Eli Levin’s Santa Fe Bohemia: The Art Colony, 1964–1980 (Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico Press, 2006; paperback with different subtitle dating, frequently cited as 2016 for the expanded or reissued edition) covers the period when the Santa Fe art scene had evolved from the founding Anglo colony era into a more diverse and commercially sophisticated world. Levin, who was himself a painter in Santa Fe during this period, writes with insider knowledge about the artists, galleries, parties, and cultural politics of a community that was simultaneously committed to artistic experimentation and deeply invested in the regional identity that the earlier generation had constructed. The festivals, particularly Indian Market and Spanish Market, figure as essential infrastructure for the art economy Levin describes.
Santa Fe Bohemia: The Art Colony, 1964–1980, by Eli Levin (Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico Press). Published in multiple editions beginning in the mid-2000s; collectors should check the edition statement carefully as the book has been revised and reissued.
Collector market: Museum of New Mexico Press first edition in Fine dust jacket: the common reading copy to mid-range zone. The book is reasonably findable in the used market and has not yet appreciated significantly. A presentation copy signed by Levin trades solid mid-range collectible value. The book’s importance for the festival collecting category comes from its documentation of the Indian Market and Spanish Market’s role in the mid-twentieth-century Santa Fe art economy—the period when the markets grew from regional arts fairs into major national cultural events.
I pick up books for free anywhere in the metro area. Call 702-496-4214 to schedule.
Three-tier collector price guide: festival books and ephemera
The collecting market for New Mexico festival books and ephemera divides naturally into three tiers based on scarcity, historical significance, and current market demand. The tier structure below provides baseline guidance; condition drives the actual price within each tier, and genuinely fine examples of early ephemera can trade multiples above the top of their tier range.
| Item / Category | Tier | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|
| SWAIA Indian Market program, 1922–1935 | Rare | serious collector territory |
| Gallup Ceremonial program, 1922–1935 | Rare | upper mid-range collectible value |
| SCAS Spanish Colonial Arts catalog, 1926–1940 | Rare | respectable collectible value |
| Santa Fe Fiesta program, 1920s–1940s | Rare | the mid-range to upper collectible zone |
| SWAIA Indian Market program, 1936–1960 | Scarce | the mid-range collectible zone |
| Gallup Ceremonial program, 1936–1960 | Scarce | the mid-range collectible zone |
| Chris Wilson, Myth of Santa Fe (UNM 1997, hardcover first/Fine) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| Weigle & Fiore, Santa Fe and Taos: The Writer’s Era (1982, cloth first) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| Mullin, Culture in the Marketplace (Duke 2001, hardcover) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| SWAIA Indian Market program, 1961–1990 | Mid-range | the common reading copy to mid-range zone |
| Dispenza & Turner, Will Shuster: A Santa Fe Legend (MNM Press 1989) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| Babcock & Monthan, The Pueblo Storyteller (UA Press 1986) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| Briggs, Wood Carvers of Córdova (UTPress 1980) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| Rodriguez, The Matachines Dance (UNM 1996, cloth first) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| Howard & Pardue, Inventing the Southwest (Heard Museum 1996) | Mid-range | solid mid-range collectible value |
| Chris Wilson, Myth of Santa Fe (UNM 1997, trade paperback) | Common/trade | the common reading copy to mid-range zone |
| Mullin, Culture in the Marketplace (Duke 2001, paperback) | Common/trade | the common reading copy to mid-range zone |
| Rodriguez, The Matachines Dance (UNM 1996, revised paperback) | Common/trade | common reading copy range |
| Lovato, Santa Fe Hispanic Culture (UNM 2004, paperback) | Common/trade | common reading copy range |
| SWAIA Indian Market program, 1991–present | Common | common reading copy range |
| Gallup Ceremonial program, 1991–present | Common | common reading copy range |
| General Southwest arts tourism guides | Common | modest value |
Festival ephemera as a collecting category: programs, posters, and award ribbons
The printed ephemera of New Mexico’s festival tradition—programs, posters, award ribbons, vendor badges, promotional broadsides, and the various paper items generated by the events each year—constitutes a distinct and underappreciated collecting category with significant historical importance. Ephemera, by definition, was not meant to survive: programs were used on the day and discarded, award ribbons were pinned to sold artwork, posters were displayed and then removed. The survival rate for early festival ephemera is low, which makes surviving examples both rare and primary sources of the first order.
The most historically significant surviving festival ephemera includes: SWAIA Indian Market award ribbons (the blue, red, and white prize ribbons awarded to artists since 1922, occasionally still attached to sold artwork; a first-place ribbon from the 1930s or 1940s is a major artifact); artist booth assignment cards and vendor badges from early market years; early Indian Market and Gallup Ceremonial posters (the poster art of both events developed into a significant genre in its own right by the 1950s and 1960s; original poster art for major markets trades respectable collectible value); and Zozobra programs and ephemera (the first Zozobra was in 1926, but no program from the first two decades has been documented in the collector market).
A note on festival ephemera provenance
Festival ephemera associated with Native American ceremonies—including dance programs, ceremonial schedules, and photography taken at restricted ceremonial events—raises provenance and cultural sensitivity questions analogous to those surrounding the ethnographic literature. Collectors should exercise judgment about items that document restricted ceremonial content: many early programs for Taos Pueblo feast days and Zuni Shalako, for example, contain photographs and descriptions that the communities involved have since requested not be reproduced. Possessing historical ephemera is legal; being thoughtful about how it is used and whether its display or reproduction respects the wishes of the communities involved is a matter of ethics rather than law.
Additional titles in the collecting market
The following titles extend the collecting market beyond the major works treated above. Each represents significant collecting value within its sub-category.
Andrew Leo Lovato, Santa Fe Hispanic Culture: Preserving Identity in a Tourist Town (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 2004). Examines the tension between Hispano cultural identity and tourist-economy pressures in contemporary Santa Fe; directly addresses the Entrada controversy’s structural roots. UNM Press trade paperback: common reading copy range.
Joe S. Sando and Herman Agoyo, eds., Po’pay: Leader of the First American Revolution (Santa Fe: Clear Light Publishers, 2005). The most important Pueblo-authored treatment of the 1680 Pueblo Revolt, whose legacy is directly implicated in the Fiesta’s Entrada controversy. Clear Light Publishers first edition: the common reading copy to mid-range zone.
Marta Weigle and Peter White, The Lore of New Mexico (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1988). Comprehensive anthology of New Mexico folklore, mythology, and cultural tradition; includes extensive documentation of festival and ceremonial traditions across both Pueblo and Hispanic communities. UNM Press cloth first edition: solid mid-range collectible value; paperback: common reading copy range.
J.J. Brody, Indian Painters and White Patrons (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1971). The foundational study of the market relationship between Native American painters and Anglo collectors; directly relevant to the Indian Market’s origins and function. UNM Press cloth first edition: the mid-range collectible zone.
Bruce Bernstein and W. Jackson Rushing, Modern by Tradition: American Indian Painting in the Studio Style (Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico Press, 1995). Documents the Studio Style of Native American painting developed at the Santa Fe Indian School and its relationship to Indian Market demand. Museum of NM Press first edition: solid mid-range collectible value.
Lonn Taylor and Dessa Bokides, New Mexican Furniture, 1600–1940: The Origins, Survival, and Revival of Furniture Making in the Hispanic Southwest (Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico Press, 1987). Authoritative treatment of the Spanish Colonial furniture tradition that the SCAS revival sought to preserve; includes documentation of Spanish Market furniture categories. Museum of NM Press cloth first edition: solid mid-range collectible value.
Beatrice Chauvenet, Hewett and Friends: A Biography of Santa Fe’s Vibrant Era (Santa Fe: Museum of New Mexico Press, 1983). The primary biographical treatment of Edgar Lee Hewett and his circle; essential context for the founding of the festival institutions. Museum of NM Press first edition: common reading copy range.
Oliver La Farge, Santa Eulalia’s People: Ritual and Reality in a Zapotec Village (or, for the La Farge Santa Fe connection, Behind the Mountains, Houghton Mifflin, 1956). La Farge, whose Laughing Boy (Houghton Mifflin, 1929) won the Pulitzer Prize, was a prominent figure in the Santa Fe cultural scene and in Native American advocacy for decades. His Santa Fe-connected work and his advocacy writing for the Indian Market era are part of the broader festival literary scene.
Frequently asked questions
What is the single most important scholarly book about Santa Fe’s cultural identity and festival tradition?
Chris Wilson’s The Myth of Santa Fe: Creating a Modern Regional Tradition (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1997) is the definitive analytical treatment of how Santa Fe constructed its identity as a cultural destination between roughly 1912 and 1940. Wilson traces the deliberate decision—made by Edgar Lee Hewett, the Museum of New Mexico, the Chamber of Commerce, and a coalition of Anglo artists and archaeologists—to brand Santa Fe as an ancient Pueblo-Spanish city with a unique architectural identity and a living craft tradition. The Indian Market, the Spanish Market, the Fiesta, and the push toward adobe building codes all figure in Wilson’s analysis as coordinated elements of a place-making project. The 1997 UNM Press hardcover first edition in Fine dust jacket trades solid mid-range collectible value; the trade paperback first edition trades the common reading copy to mid-range zone.
What are the most collectible SWAIA Indian Market catalogs and what do they trade for?
SWAIA has published official programs and award catalogs continuously since 1922, creating a run of over a century of primary documentation. Early issues—particularly 1922 through 1940—are fragile, difficult to authenticate without deep familiarity, and rarely surface outside institutional collections. True 1920s issues in collector condition trade serious collector territory per issue; 1930s issues trade respectable collectible value; 1940s–1950s issues trade the mid-range collectible zone. The post-1960 run is far more common: 1960s–1980s issues trade the common reading copy to mid-range zone; 1990s–2010s issues trade common reading copy range. Condition is critical for the early issues, as most surviving examples show significant wear from use at the market. Collectors should also look for SWAIA commemorative publications for major anniversaries (50th in 1972, 75th in 1997, centennial in 2022), which are issued in larger quantities but carry specific anniversary collecting interest.
What are the key points of issue for Chris Wilson’s The Myth of Santa Fe (1997)?
Published by the University of New Mexico Press in 1997 in two simultaneous forms: hardcover (ISBN 0-8263-1745-7) and trade paperback (ISBN 0-8263-1746-5). The hardcover first edition is identifiable by the copyright page, which reads “First edition” with no additional printing history. Later paperback printings carry additional printing history on the copyright page. The hardcover dust jacket features a period photograph of a Santa Fe street scene and should be price-intact for maximum value. The hardcover first edition in Fine/Fine condition trades solid mid-range collectible value; the paperback first edition trades the common reading copy to mid-range zone. A presentation copy signed by Wilson—a prominent figure in New Mexico cultural heritage circles—would trade respectable collectible value for hardcover.
What are Gallup Inter-Tribal Indian Ceremonial programs and why are early issues so scarce?
The Gallup Inter-Tribal Indian Ceremonial has published official programs continuously since its 1922 founding, exactly contemporaneous with the SWAIA Indian Market catalog run. Early programs from the 1920s and 1930s are among the rarest pieces of New Mexico festival ephemera: printed in small quantities for a regional event before Route 66 brought tourist traffic to Gallup, handled and discarded by attendees, and not systematically preserved. The programs document tribal participants, dance schedules, trade fair information, and the regional business environment that supported the event. True 1920s Gallup programs in readable condition trade upper mid-range collectible value; 1930s issues trade respectable collectible value; 1940s–1950s issues trade the mid-range collectible zone. Comprehensive institutional holdings are rare even in New Mexico libraries; a complete run from 1922 to the present is essentially nonexistent in any single collection.
What is Molly Mullin’s Culture in the Marketplace about and why does it matter for collectors?
Molly Mullin’s Culture in the Marketplace: Gender, Art, and Value in the American Southwest (Durham: Duke University Press, 2001) is the most rigorous sociological analysis of what the Indian Market, Spanish Market, and associated Santa Fe cultural economy actually do: who benefits, who is excluded, how value is assigned, and how gender shapes all of these processes. Working from 1990s fieldwork at the markets and in the Santa Fe art world, Mullin analyzes how Native American and Hispanic arts are commodified, authenticated, and marketed, and how the system of cultural brokerage established in the 1920s has evolved. For collectors, the Mullin is essential because it provides the analytical framework that contextualizes everything else in this collecting category. The Duke University Press hardcover first edition (2001) trades solid mid-range collectible value in Very Good or better condition; the paperback edition trades the common reading copy to mid-range zone.
What is the Entrada controversy and what books cover it?
The Entrada pageant was the centerpiece of the annual Santa Fe Fiesta for most of the twentieth century: a theatrical re-enactment of Don Diego de Vargas’s 1692 reconquest of Santa Fe. Pueblo communities—particularly Ohkay Owingeh—had long objected to the pageant’s glorification of colonial conquest. In 2018, after sustained protest, the traditional Entrada march was discontinued. The scholarly literature most directly relevant includes Andrew Leo Lovato’s Santa Fe Hispanic Culture (UNM Press, 2004), Joe Sando and Herman Agoyo’s Po’pay: Leader of the First American Revolution (Clear Light, 2005), and Chris Wilson’s Myth of Santa Fe, which provides the structural context. Early Fiesta programs (1920s–1940s) that include the Entrada pageant script are primary documents for this history and trade the mid-range to upper collectible zone.
Who was Will Shuster and what books cover Zozobra?
Will Shuster (1893–1969) was a Philadelphia-born painter who came to Santa Fe in 1920 as a tuberculosis health-seeker and stayed for life. In 1926 he created Zozobra for the Santa Fe Fiesta—a giant puppet figure representing “Old Man Gloom,” stuffed with shredded paper and burned annually in Fort Marcy Park. Shuster modeled the ceremony on Yaqui and Pueblo fire ritual and donated it to the Kiwanis Club of Santa Fe in 1964. The current Zozobra stands fifty feet tall and draws crowds of 50,000. The primary book about Shuster is Joseph Dispenza and Louise Turner’s Will Shuster: A Santa Fe Legend (Museum of New Mexico Press, 1989), which trades solid mid-range collectible value in Fine condition with dust jacket. Shuster was also a founding member of Los Cinco Pintores; exhibition catalogs from their 1920s shows are significant collectibles.
What is Weigle and Fiore’s Santa Fe and Taos: The Writer’s Era and how does it relate to festival collecting?
Santa Fe and Taos: The Writer’s Era, 1916–1941, edited by Marta Weigle and Kyle Fiore (Santa Fe: Ancient City Press, 1982), is an anthology of primary sources covering the literary and artistic colonization of northern New Mexico by the Anglo writer-artist communities who established themselves in Santa Fe and Taos during and after World War I. The volume includes excerpts from Mary Austin, Witter Bynner, D.H. Lawrence, Mabel Dodge Luhan, and others who were simultaneously the audience for and the promoters of the emerging festival culture. The Ancient City Press cloth first edition (1982) trades solid mid-range collectible value in Fine condition; the trade paperback trades the common reading copy to mid-range zone. The book has not been reprinted and is becoming difficult to find in Fine condition.
What are the key books about the Spanish Colonial Arts Society and Spanish Market?
The Spanish Colonial Arts Society was founded in 1925 by Frank Applegate and Mary Austin to revive and preserve New Mexico’s Spanish Colonial craft traditions; the first Spanish Market was held in 1926. Early SCAS exhibition catalogs (1926–1940) are among the rarest pieces of New Mexico cultural ephemera, trading respectable collectible value when they surface. Key scholarly treatments include Charles Briggs’s The Wood Carvers of Córdova, New Mexico (University of Tennessee Press, 1980, solid mid-range collectible value) and Lonn Taylor and Dessa Bokides’s New Mexican Furniture, 1600–1940 (Museum of New Mexico Press, 1987, solid mid-range collectible value). The SCAS has also published monographs and catalogs on specific Spanish Colonial art forms—tinwork, colcha embroidery, furniture—that are standard references for collectors of the physical objects as well as the books.
Where should I donate books about New Mexico cultural festivals, Indian Market, and Spanish Market?
NMLP picks up free anywhere in the central New Mexico service area—Albuquerque metro, Santa Fe, Espanola, Las Vegas NM, Socorro, Belen, Rio Rancho—with no minimum and no condition requirement. Festival and cultural-market books I particularly want: any SWAIA Indian Market catalog or award publication (especially pre-1960 issues); any Gallup Inter-Tribal Indian Ceremonial program (especially 1922–1950); any Santa Fe Fiesta program (especially pre-1960, or any Entrada-related publication); Chris Wilson’s Myth of Santa Fe (UNM Press, 1997, especially hardcover first edition); Marta Weigle and Kyle Fiore’s Santa Fe and Taos: The Writer’s Era (Ancient City Press, 1982); any SCAS Spanish Colonial Arts Society publication; Molly Mullin’s Culture in the Marketplace (Duke, 2001); Sylvia Rodriguez’s The Matachines Dance (UNM, 1996); Dispenza and Turner’s Will Shuster: A Santa Fe Legend (Museum of NM Press, 1989); Babcock and Monthan’s The Pueblo Storyteller (UA Press, 1986); any Fred Harvey Company or ATSF Railway publication featuring New Mexico arts; any Los Cinco Pintores or Will Shuster exhibition catalog. Drop-off 24/7 at 5445 Edith Blvd NE, Unit A, Albuquerque NM 87107, or schedule free pickup at newmexicoliteracyproject.org/free-book-pickup-albuquerque or call/text 702-496-4214.
About this pillar
This reference was compiled by Josh Eldred at New Mexico Literacy Project, 5445 Edith Blvd NE Unit A, Albuquerque NM 87107. NMLP processes thousands of New Mexico regional books annually and has developed collecting-market expertise across all major categories of New Mexico regional literature, ephemera, and cultural documentation.
Donate New Mexico cultural festival books, SWAIA catalogs, Gallup Ceremonial programs, Fiesta programs, and related ephemera: free pickup anywhere in central New Mexico at newmexicoliteracyproject.org/free-book-pickup-albuquerque or call/text 702-496-4214. Drop-off 24/7 at my Edith Blvd location.
Cite This Guide
Eldred, J. (May 2026). New Mexico Fiestas, Indian Market, Spanish Market & Cultural Festivals — Book & Ephemera Collecting. New Mexico Literacy Project.
https://newmexicoliteracyproject.org/new-mexico-fiestas-indian-market-spanish-market-books-collecting
Content is original research by Josh Eldred. Licensed under CC BY 4.0. Cite with attribution.